Top court backs inventor in Hitachi suit The Associated Press The Supreme Court ruled Tuesday in favor of inventor rights in a patent dispute between electronics maker Hitachi Ltd. and a former employer who invented technology for reading CDs and DVDs. The top court ruling on a Hitachi appeal backs a January 2004 decision by the Tokyo High Court that awarded Seiji Yonezawa 163 million yen, Hitachi and a court official said. The Tokyo High Court said at the time that Tokyo-based Hitachi had failed to compensate Yonezawa adequately for his invention. "This is a historic ruling," said Hidetoshi Masunaga, Yonezawa's lawyer. "It's simply fantastic." Hitachi contested the ruling, which had awarded more money than a 2002 Tokyo District Court ruling that did not include compensation for overseas profits. Hitachi said in a statement the ruling was "regrettable." "We fear that this decision may greatly hinder the research development and business efforts of Japanese companies," it said. Yonezawa's lawyers have said he was paid only 118,000 yen for one of three patents he filed between 1973 and 1977 for technology used to read CDs and DVDs. Yonezawa, who retired from Hitachi in 1996, had demanded 250 million yen in royalties. Hitachi claimed it already paid him for the patents. In recent years, there has been a rise in legal disputes over intellectual property as inventors have begun to assert their rights more forcefully in a nation that has long fostered corporate loyalty among employees. Some companies never spelled out terms of patent royalty payments in their contracts and some scientists have complained they were not adequately compensated for lucrative inventions. Until recent years, major companies had a system of lifetime employment, under which employees were assured a job for life but were not rewarded based on performance. Another high-profile courtroom battle over patents was settled last year for 840 million yen. In that case, inventor Shuji Nakamura had demanded compensation from Nichia Corp. over patents he filed for the blue light-emitting diode, or LED, widely used in traffic lights and cell phones. He was awarded a record 20 billion yen in 2004.