ログインしてさらにmixiを楽しもう

コメントを投稿して情報交換!
更新通知を受け取って、最新情報をゲット!

英語:racismコミュのIf you don't like Japan, go home!

  • mixiチェック
  • このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
I have heard the above argument several times in response to complaints about how the Japanese do things.
I think it is a ridiculous comment.
My thinking is that if something is wrong, it is ok to change it or to take steps to try and change it. I think there is and has been a lot of racism in Canada and I am glad that different immigrants and immigrant groups have made their voices heard and became forces for change in my country. I think the same thing can and should happen in Japan.
I would like to hear others point of view on this.

Jeff

コメント(35)

Basically I agree with Jeff.
If you like Japan, change it!
It's better to do something against racism or kind of it, not only complaining. But at the same time, it's important to me just to hear complains. Not only immigrants but Japanese can change this situation. Indeed, some Japanese groups keep trying it.
...Well, actually I don't read all comments yet because I don't have enough English skill to do it. sorry about it.
"If you are in Rome do as the Romans do."

Immigrants,foreigners,ethnic and religous minorities should have no say in the way the country is run.Muslims in Italy tried to ban the cross from the classroom and in Holland killed the nephew of Van gogh because he critisized terrorism and muslim fundamentalism IN HOLLAND!If we allow these people to change values,ideals and way of living in the host country then we would finish up like the UK - more muslims than english in the house of commons.When I was in Japan I embraced myself in the new culture and live don with it.At first it was hard(to eat with chopsticks and sleep on the floor) but now I can really understand it.How I would like to sleep on a futon again!

Places like Japan that have a very old traditional lifestyle should not change to accomodate foreigners.Remember that Canada is only a few centuries old and that a country like Japan and other countries such as mine have indeed thousands of years of tradition and history which are not that easy to eradicate.Not speaking about Japan but on my country:if some foreigner does not like my country well he must get out of here then.
I agree with you al (mostly cause I looked at your homepage and you are one big dude).
Seriously though I do agree that Japan is good how it is mostly. I love it. If I didn't I won't be here right. That doesn't mean its perfect. Attitutes could change and laws could change.
Andre is obviously from somewhere different than I and feels alot more strongly about immigrants. I can't really comment on it too much until I have walked in his shoes. Canada is younger and is built on immigrants. Even if you are white you are still an immigrant here. The only non immigrants are the first nations.
side note, Al what part of KANADA are you from?
I agree that things that are blatantly racist sshould be voiced but some foreigners complain too much about things that are part of this culture. Every culture has its differences and they should accept it...if you can't and keep complaining about how much you hate the Japanese way of doing things, then get out.
I agree with Gyutan as well. I feel that when people go to a foreign country they often complain about differences from their own country. They need to research deeper and usually there are reasons why something is done that way.
people shouldn't be too quick to complain about things without doing the research.
On the other hand some things are just wrong and need to be changed.
One example I can throw out I guess:
In Japan, to my understanding, it is impossible to rape your wife.
It used to be that way in North America as well. Rape in Canada used to be defined as unwanted sex with someone who is not your wife. That means that Japanese men can force their wifes to have sex and it is not rape.
if I am wrong, please correct me but that is my understanding of the law.
those kind of blatent things need changing.
Wow!We need a law like that in our country.No more 'I have got a headache' excuse!Japan is getting more interesting it seems.
Relax Jeff.Japanese girls may look sweet innocent and docile but that's the wrong impression.I think they might give you a nice martial art punch or kick if they are in a situation like this!Right Ruri?hehe lol
Dear Jeff;

one of the articles(177) of Japanese criminal law says
"第百七十七条  暴行又は脅迫を用いて十三歳以上の女子を姦淫した者は、強姦の罪とし、三年以上の有期懲役に処する。十三歳未満の女子を姦淫した者も、同様とする。"
which means if you rape female who is either older than 13 years old or younger than that, will be sentenced to 3 years.
...so technically it's is possible to charge one's husband for rape although it's hard to prove it.
And there is only one case in Japan that I could find on the internet, which a guy was sentenced for raping his wife.
In this case,
-they were separted for a while.(their marrige was broken down.)
-the guy was crazy enough to rape his wife with his friend(s?)

The idea of that you have obligation to have sex with your partner if you are married is the concept for when you are trying to get divorce I think.
I mean you have right to ask for sex with your wife and if she refuses, you can DIVORCE but NOT RAPE.

I am not expert on Japanese law so I can be wrong for some stuff:p

I don't know why I was so eager to do reasearch in this topic although I'm not married, but at least I have some idea in Japanese law better than before. hehe:p
>>jeff

>Japanese men can force their wifes to have sex and it is not rape.
Still now!? It's shocking and disgusting.
I don't know about law well, but I understand when wifes use "DV防止法(通称)", they can sue their husband for rape. And I hope... they will win and divorce.

DV防止法(通称) aims to stop domestic violence.
I think I was incorrect on my understanding of the relevant Japanese Rape Law. Article 177 seems fairly clear to me that it is possible to charge a man with raping his wife. I had this discussion with a Japanese Law professor several years ago and came away with the impression, without myself reading the laws, that a man can rape his wife in Japan without consequence.
If I had more time I would review some case law on how the Japanese judiciary has interpreted article 177.
Maybe what was being referred to was the actual difficulty in pushing that charge through the justice system. Or the law has been amended since our conversation.
Well I did some research before posting this and found this

“The Penal Code simply says "A person who forcibly or threateningly has sexual intercourse with a woman should be punished as having committed a crime of rape." However, courts and legal scholars have interpreted and continue to interpret this clause to mean that "a legally married wife" should be excluded from the definition of a woman in the code as regards the rape law. Therefore, a wife cannot be "legally" raped by her husband even though she was "actually" raped by her husband. So, a marriage registration is a husband's license for rape. This is why elderly Japanese women actually used to call sex with their husbands a "duty" (in Japanese, "otsutome"). Even if wifes do not know the Penal Code, they know well its consequences for them. They must accept whatever sexual demands their husbands impose on them because the legal system allows it. It is easy to understand how this justification for marital rape encourages men to act violently in the domestic sphere and guarantees that right.”

This is the source.

http://www.tuj.ac.jp/newsite/main/law/lawresources/TUJonline/SexualDiscrimination/tsunodasexualharrassment.html

It is from Temple Law School in Japan.

sorry for not doing my research earlier.
Jeff
Al - I am from Calgary, I like to see other Canadians on here.
"Immigrants,foreigners,ethnic and religous minorities should have no say in the way the country is run."

.. and you're an international relations major? That sounds absurdly mid-west American. haha
If people don't try to accommodate other people, the world is going to be in a lot of trouble. The religious groups need to understand that not everybody is part of their religion, and secular groups need to understand that there are religious people around.
Any time you suggest that a certain group of people in a society should have no rights, it should trigger an automatic warning in your head that you're probably mistaken. When is it ever the case that a group of people should have no rights unless they've done something in violation of the non-verbal social contract? Even in America, all the illegal immigrants who come to make money and live off the tax paying citizen's dollars have certain rights because they're people, not animals.
That is not what I said - you misunderstood me 100% lad.
Did I say something against not accomodating immigrants?
Did I say something against the rights of ethnic minorities in a country?Where please?Point it out for me.
Of course they should have rights - but not change the values and way the country is run.
You are wrong man - if ethnic minorities have the power to change how the country is run - then we will have lots of trouble in the future.International rights are a must but not the abusing of the system including interference in politics.
Yes, you did say exactly that, right here:
"Immigrants,foreigners,ethnic and religous minorities should have no say in the way the country is run."
Rights are having a say in the way the country is run.

"if ethnic minorities have the power to change how the country is run - then we will have lots of trouble in the future."
Do you have any reason to think that? I can think of several societies where ethnic minorities have no "power to change how the country is run" and they're all doing much worse in pretty much every regard compared to America and Canada. America is actually in a big debate right now about ILLEGAL immigrants, and their power. Legal immigrants are agreed to have social powers (as well they should) and it works out fine. What evidence do you have to support your claim that minorities should have no power?
Listen up man,

You decide to invite some people to your house.You have dinner together,talk and have a drink,watch some dvd or movie together,chill out in the garden or backyard and then say goodbye.The guests leave and they invite you to their house next time.

You decide to invite some people to your house.You have dinner together while at the same time they stand up and open up your fridge and take food from it.They take some drink without your permission when you are not watching,they go upstairs and downstairs,in and out,back anf forth all the time - they start running and jumping on your bed and switching on and off appliances.Then they decide to sleep in your bed while you sleep on the sofa.

Hope you got my point.Was it clear enough?
Metaphorically speaking of course :P lol
I am sure you applied for a visa and had to undergo certain procedures before going in though.
Um,Al kun,the whole talk is about different types of immigrants-the ones that accept their new country and live like the locals and those who want to change the host country to suit their interests.The one above is just an example when unwanted guests start controlling the country(your house that is).If you are happy or it is OK for you that migrants should control Canada,then it is your problem.But hell no.I won't let them control my country.

And my God,who mentioned racism anyway?Is defending your space racism?I think you should check the definition of racism in the dictionary mate.
but working to change the culture of a country you moved to is also wrong and i am against that,>We agree here.That is what I have been saying all along!

basically im for everyone living how they want :P>Anarchy you mean?No rules?No regulations?No law enforcement?Expand on this please.Its too vague man.
That's not fair OK!X - I have nothing else left to say!

Well Al Kun,You can of course live your life and everything but it is very unpolite to impose your way on locals.That's all.Japan is a free country but it has its tradition,values and ways and they must be safeguarded because they are the result of the blood and toil of the Japanese that lived there in the past.It is thanks to them that Japan is a very culturally rich nation today.
Spot on, my friend.Infact when logging into MIXI is like being in Japan.It has this effect on me that I cannot explain lol
This seems to be a dormant community.Maybe we should spice it up a little bit?
But what exactly is in your mind?What should the Japanese be taught in schools?
I was very surprised to hear this because we have the same situation over here.Indeed the media is led by communist hippies and liberals.These people are very dangerous and as you correctly said before me,the education system and media is a propoganda machine to make Maltese ashamed of their culture and identity.They break the spinal bone of our students at school too.As a result of this,many Maltese are ashamed of their culture and even the language.Many indeed prefer to speak English rather than use Maltese!

I can see a parallelity with Japan.Indeed these communist bastards are everywhere.Them and those international manipulators.

http://judicial-inc.biz/Bush_Mossad11.htm
Hi all.
It was an interesting topic, so I'd like to make a short comment. No matter which counrty you go, there's ALWAYS some people say "if you don't like my country, then go back to your f*cking counrty."
What I am trying to say here is it's not only Japanese people say that but all others.
It's almost 2007, we NEED TO understand difference of cultures and be respectful to everyone!

ログインすると、残り12件のコメントが見れるよ

mixiユーザー
ログインしてコメントしよう!

英語:racism 更新情報

英語:racismのメンバーはこんなコミュニティにも参加しています

星印の数は、共通して参加しているメンバーが多いほど増えます。

人気コミュニティランキング