Dear friends from "The United States" community on Mixi,
This user entitled "大尉" who has been causing us trouble, finally decided to leave this group, thanks God! Thus, the following topics were consequently deleted since the same were the cause of conflicts amoung members envolving racial segregation and other kinds of discrimination. 民主主義 又少しだけアメリカが良くなった。 I have been getting several emails from other members of this group, with claims corcening this user. Now that he is gone, I think we can all have peace and continue making this community one of the most popular ones on Mixi. Thanks again for all of you who helped me to deal with him.
Rob
Here is the message I sent him just a few minutes before he decided to leave. ---------------------------------------------------- This is Rob, the moderator of the community entitled "United States" here on Mixi. I created this community with the aim of bringing to its members a place where we can have any kinds of discussions, about a great variety of topics, be them political issues, cultural issues, or any other kinds. I am writing to you this time, because recently I have been getting complains from other members who have been asking me to put you out of our community. In other to protect the privacy of our members, I cannot tell you who they are, but I can tell you there are several of them, who already contacted me during these last two weeks. As you should know, they are complaining about your behavior. It seems like the way you write is somehow extremely offensive, and most of the contents of your postings show yourself as person who wants to promote racial segregation and wants make efforts to proliferate it. Unless you change your behavior, I have no other choice, but to conduct a survey on this community to discuss what measures should be taking concerning your membership. Once again, let me remind you that this place is a free area, where people are free to expose their opinions and ideas. But you are going a little bit too far. Verbaly attacking other members is called defamation, and that is what you have been doing, sir.
As you can see by looking at the replies of this topic, it seems that most of us wanted it.
But I really agree that I should have asked everybody else involved in this topic.
If the same case happens again, I will make sure that we conduct a survey here before taking any actions.
Thanks for your comment and please accept my apologies.
Dear Yozo,
I read your comment on my decision and I really think I have to apolozige for not asking the opinion of all the members involved on the topic 民主主義 and also for not asking the authorization of Nikki.
Please accept my apologies. It seems like you were enjoying this discussion. What we can do is re-open the same discussion now.
Friends,
Thanks for letting me know your opinions.
I will make efforts that from now on, this community will be leaded not only by myself, but by the cooperation and support of all of you.
Thank you, Rob, for dealing with the problems.
Well, after all, I think the starter of this community (in this case, who is Rob) has an authority to decide what will be an appropriate topic or who will be the member of this community.
If one disagrees or does not like the community, he can leave like 大尉 did.
So thanks again, Rob.
Peace.
And to Rob, I got to apologize about whatever I mentioned to ignite this poster. I didn't mean it and I still hope he learned something out of it. I was busy especially after the bombings took place in London, I did whole lot of reading and browsing and talking to friends for the last 4 days (also playing music with fellows from England).
But you were probably busy taking care of this matter while the original poster, who is me, had been away. I give the total respect to your decision. Thanks a lot.
> 11: Nikki
Nikki, Thanks. I also hope he learned something out of it. I tried to talk to him, but we have been experiencing some problems since apparently he doesn't understand English and my Japanese skills are not enough for this kind of discussion. There are still a lot of historical and political terms that I don't know in Japanese. By the way, are your British friends all right?
いいえ、私が言っていた差別はそこの表現ではありません。
直接個人宛に「あなたは禁治産者である」とか、「あなたはキモイですよ」とかというメールが届いていますよ。
それで、管理者側にメールが届いています。
I am very sure this is called "defamation". If you say this is not defamation, then I really don't know what it means.
Rob, thanks again. I actually don't have any friends who live in England. But I met 2 young men at a British bar Friday night. They just came to Japan several days earlier and going to go back at the end of July. We sang "Imagine" together and it saved my day. I hope it did the same to them. What we need is simple understanding but we all seem to keep failing. Peace.
Well, I wish I could've had the chance to read what was
posted by the said individual....but I guess I'm out of
luck since it's already been deleted.
A heated debate isn't necessarily a bad thing. It
causes people to dig deep and think hard, and it may
even help some people in finding out where they
actually stand.
Debate is good! Discussion and the free exchange of
ideas is always good.
I don't agree with everything I read (it seems much was
already deleted) but it's too bad the "TAII" was kicked out.
"Freedom of Speech" is what America is all about. It
is truly ironic that his freedom of speech was censored on a website called "United States of America". Wow.
As a reminder, it is still LEGAL in America to be :
1. Stupid
2. Gay
3. Racist
4. Poor
5. Communist
6. Anarchist
7. Agnostic
8. Religious
9. Socialist
10. Or anything else you disagree with
In my opinion, if someone wants to share his opinions,
no matter how different from mine, then he should be
allowed to. People are intelligent and have the ability
to think for themselves.
If someone is offended, that is just how life goes.
In LIFE, you're going to get offended from time to time.
Not much we can do about it.
>>"Freedom of Speech" is what America is all about. It
is truly ironic that his freedom of speech was censored on a website called "United States of America". Wow.
Thanks for your comment on the FREEDOM OF SPEECH issue.
Sometimes I wonder what this country is coming to. No
one can say or do anything offensive to anyone! We are
so politically correct it makes me feel sick inside.
Can't use the word "illegal alien", have to say the
term "undocumented worker" etc...
If I say anything negative about illegal aliens, or how
they are using our emergency rooms and flooding our
schools, and filling our jails I am labled a "racist".
Can't say "black" unless you are black. Can't say
anything negative or funny about anything anymore. This country is turning into a bunch of pussies!!
By the way, I NEVER use the term "African-American" or
"Asian-American" etc...afterall, no one uses the word
"European-American"! They just call us all "white".
Even the media uses the word "white" but refers to all
other races as "(something)-American". Why is this?
Isn't THIS racism??
Our founding fathers kicked ass to make this country a
place were men could be FREE from oppression and
censorship.
I think they would be disgusted and disappointed if
they saw what we had become.
I deleted my last posting because it is not appropriate.
Here, I want to apologize to Rob, the community moderator, for the critical contents against him in that posting without enough confirming, while I mentioned sensitive matter.
In this case, I should have make a contact with him at first.
Hi there. Sunshine, you got a good point here. To me, it is funny that people try to be politically correct, I feel that it is nothing but hypocritical. Everybody’s so sensitive nowadays, it seems almost paranoia. I live in Japan and work with a Nigerian guy and I deal with illegal aliens and Embassy people, black, white and yellow on everyday basis because of my business. I also deal with lots of Africans because of my NPO activities. But I admit that I am a bit of a racist myself. I mean we all are. We are all bit of an egoist and we should be.
People worry too much. People try to protect and make sure that he or she can defend themselves. It’s a nature of what we are to be protective to some degree. But it is getting to the point of ridicule.
I used to love listening to Howie Stern radio show. He was so funny. He would make fun of Chinese and Japanese and Blacks, etc. in a good sense of humor. To me, Howie was a great American. He didn’t protect himself. He was not a hypocrite. We would be in a better world if we could laugh at each other for how different we are….
I agree with everybody with regard to the freedom of speech. On the other hand, we must also observe rules and regulations of the media we are using.
Neither Rob himself nor I think this issue was handled appropriately. However, if Mixi determines there are discriminatory or defamatory exchanges in a community, Mixi reserves the right to terminate the community without a consent from the community administrator.
When Rob returns, we should all discuss how we can honor the freedom of speech in this community without victimizing our members or violating Mixi's rules and regulations.
I must take exception to your comments concerning "Freedom of Speech" especially in context to American society and culture.
You stated:
>>"Freedom of Speech" is what America is all about. It
is truly ironic that his freedom of speech was censored on a website called "United States of America". Wow.>>
You would lead readers of this blog that all forms of speech are protected in the United States. Perhaps you could research Oliver Wendell Holmes in Schenk vs. United States in 1917 where he stated not all forms of expression are protected. For instance, someone cannot falsely yell fire in a crowded theater, because it can interfere with the rights of other people who are there, and they can be harmed. Without going into legal minutia, in essense your right of self-expression ends where it interferes with other peoples rights.
You stated:
>> I don't agree with everything I read (it seems much was
already deleted) but it's too bad the "TAII" was kicked out.>>
That is misleading also. Rob the moderator, as is his job as moderator of this group, believed his words and ideas were detrimental to the purpose of this community, which I agree with Rob. He asked TAII to tone it down, and TAII left, he was not kicked out.
You stated:
>> Thanks for your comment on the FREEDOM OF SPEECH issue.
Sometimes I wonder what this country is coming to. No
one can say or do anything offensive to anyone! We are
so politically correct it makes me feel sick inside.>>
Aside from the fact that one in the United States can legally still use the term, "Illegal Alien", instead of "Undocumented Worker", or "Negro or variations of that term", or "Jap" as opposed to "Japanese". Does that aid in any type of communication? Or by using those terms, does that throw up blocks that just adds to discontent and helps no one at all, just making society more fragmented.
There are many venues and blogs on the Internet where calling groups of people what they do not want be called is fashionable, one might
try : http://dir.yahoo.com/Society_and_Culture/Cultures_and_Groups/White_Pride_and_Racialism/
As a member of this community dedicated to the mutual understanding of American and Japanese culture, I for one do not wish to portray the ugly ideas of American racism here, nor do I adhere to such ideas.