i agree, both are very different..and they both have their good points...Facebook is much easier to find friends, and I like sharing photo albums..Mixi feels more like a blog with the journal entries and the communities...I'm enjoying both at the moment:)
I like the blog aspect of Mixi - on Mixi real actually conversations are more or less (unintentionally) promoted just by Mixi's format alone. Facebook is more about "droppin a couple of lines here and there", leaving comments - not fostering actual conversations.
Mixi can be a little restrictive I suppose, but I don't want the facebook atmosphere and all the random crap that facebook adds on to accounts and shit. If I did, I'd have a facebook account.
It's common knowledge that Japanese people are Scared Of The Internet (it's a relatively old article from last year but read http://neojaponisme.com/2009/05/19/the-fear-of-the-internet/ for details).
So to that extent, the anonymity of Mixi compared to facebook and myspace is understandable if not frustrating to those of us who are used to the relative openness of Western SNSes.
I personally stopped using Facebook as much after all the stupid apps for which people sent nonstop invitations to start using. It's very disappointing that Mixi has gone down the same path but at least it doesn't send me 100 Sunshine Farm emails daily.
I do wish we could have better photo capabilities, but that also comes from the reliance of many Mixi users on their keitai...
This may have been brought up before, but one thing I wish Mixi did is to make itself more accessible to the non-Japanese cellphone and smartphone users.
Facebook Mobile and Facebook for iPhone are both very well made. On the other hand, the Mixi app for iPhone is a POS. Worse yet, their "mobile" site is only accessible from the Japanese "keitai" cellphones.
As the result, I spend far more time on Facebook than Mixi these days.
I think they have different strong points.
Mixi has アプリ and other special features like reviews and forum-like communities.
Also it has ashiato, which I love because it makes mixi safer, since you know who saw your profile.
But, in the other hand, it's very difficult to upload photos here.
Only 5 at a time, only jpg and only up to 5MB.
Facebook, on the contrary, is great for sharing photos, and getting in touch with your friends is way easier.
(Most) people use their names, and not weird nicknames, so it's easy to find friends.
However, it doesn't offer cool apps, it's more insecure because anyone can join without invitation and
its annoying to be invited to so many things you're not interested in.
Anyway, I don't think mixi is trying to become Facebook, it's just exploiting another niche market .
>>ハモンド星人
>But then, you have the ability to erase your "Footprint"...
Which they (wisely) limited to 10 times a month. I dunno about you but I click a lot of profiles randomly DAILY, so I see no problem with such a limited ability.
>> However, (Facebook) doesn't offer cool apps....
I'm not sure I agree. As far as I can tell, Facebook offers far more cool applications than Mixi does. Besides, most if not all the arguably "cool" Mixi apps look like dead copycats of the Facebook counterparts.
I may be wrong (after all, my Japanese is lousy) but the way I see things:
Facebook is more for keeping contact with friends and acquaintances. Just look at the search features: unless you know the name and/or email address, you can hardly find anyone. It's far away from MySpace, which allows to search by location, age etc... Or you have to play it "6 degrees of separation" style and browse your friends' friends... which can be tedious, to say the least.
Mixi, to my point of view, is actually closer to MySpace than Facebook. Not that the search features on Mixi are that great either, but I feel it's more a place to show-off. "Here's my blog, here are my pics and videos. Check my stuff and comment."
I made a good real-life friend through Mixi, and also met a couple of photo models. So I won't complain too much. I just don't expect miracles. Wasn't Mixi a Japan-only site, would we use it? Not that sure, especially now that other SNS have a Japanese language interface...
I was writing about the search feature on Facebook. I rarely used the one on Mixi.I don't even know if it changed or not.
Can one search by age/location... on Mixi?
Even though more and more people tend to password-protect their data, I still see Mixi as more of a blogging alternative, not really a social network. Networking takes time, something that many people seem to lack nowadays.
As for the communities... didn't we have all these things already? First, on BBS, then on Usenet, and finally on internet discussion boards?
See, I joined quite a lot here on Mixi, but mostly through friends invite or as an easy way to show what I like.
But if I wanted to discuss with, say, other King Crimson fans or other Alfred Hitchcock fans, I would search for more active, bigger communities outside of Mixi.
Main, not to say only interest to use the ones here would be to find people living nearby (Kyoto area), sharing the same interests and wishing to meet in real-life, since I way prefer good old face-to-face chatting.
Thus leading back to my opinion: if Mixi wasn't a Japanese-only thing (not just for the language, but the geographic area), would we use it since everything that Mixi has to offer, all in all, we can already find it elsewhere?
Mixi released the earnings result for the full fiscal year 2010 on its website. According to the report, Mixi now has 23.37 million users, saw sales growing 24.1% year-year-on-year, and operating income growing 22.5%.
My view of features like "Ashiato" on MIXI or "Who viewed my profile" on Orkut and other Social Networks are not only for security. How it can work for make you safer? Know who had browsed your profile doesn't make we safer.
I think the reason of this feature is to get more people connected. It's to stimulate clicks and views, messages between the users. I do always click at the profiles who browsed me. Sometimes I even write then to keep in touch if we have common interests.
I think the question of this topic started after MIXI copied the feature "Like" from Facebook, (イイね). And
a feature similar with Twitter's twits was also included.
As a Japanese social network MIXI is provinding the best of his original ideas like Diary and his original
design added by the best of Orkut (communities) Facebook (Like possibility) and Twitter dynamics on pc and mobile platforms.
>>Mixi has アプリ and other special features like reviews and forum-like communities.
Facebook also has this...It has "apps" and games and stuff, and the various groups and celebrity pages also have discussion boards... I guess Facebook doesn't have reviews though.
>>>Also it has ashiato, which I love because it makes mixi safer, since you know who saw your profile.
I don't see how that makes mixi safer than Facebook. On facebook, I know who can see my profile--No one that's not on my friends list because I set my privacy so that no one can see me.
I don't know most of the people who see my profile on mixi. And if they happened to be crazy murderer who were stalking me to kill me, I wouldn't know it just because they are on my ashiato. It doesn't make you safer at all, it's just so you can look at people who saw your profile and go "Wow, this person is hot!" and then maybe you will want to get to know them or send a friend request. If anything it makes you less safe, because then if you go to someone's page, it's almost like an invitation for them to look at your page.
>>>However, it doesn't offer cool apps, it's more insecure because anyone can join without invitation and its annoying to be invited to so many things you're not interested in.
Facebook has a lot of "cool apps," similar to how Mixi does. Also, you never have to click on those invitations. Iknow I never do. The number on the side goes up every day, but I just don't click them. Although now with the newer Facebook profile that makes it harder to see apps on your profile, the number of invitations has decreased. ALso, I get invited to stupid crap I'm not interested here on Mixi just like on Facebook!!!
Honestly, I love Mixi, but pretty much only because it's in Japanese. If it were the same thing, but in English/for American audiences, I wouldn't use it at all...
Mixi is Japanese and only let's in people with Japanese cellphones to register. Except this and some few other English communities, you won't be able to understand anything unless you know Japanese.
Facebook is international and became a fashion - how else it would be possible that 12yo members use FB too? I've got mostly Japanese, Chinese or Taiwanese friends on FB that I keep in touch with
35>>*There isn't a week passing by without getting tens of app & spam posts in FB.
So, FB's security measures are still vulnerable to spam & viral attacks, which I didn't get in my 4 years of using Mixi...
You can hide/block apps, so I literally never see any app posts. As for the spam and viral attacks, people generally get those by clicking on links that are very obviously fake/contaminated. If people thought more before clicking everything they see...
Like, when someone you have not talked to in years sending you a chat message or posts on your wall saying "I tagged you in a photo, click this link!", it should be obvious that it's fake, when facebook did not send an official notification about it...
i think mixi and face-book are almost the same belonging to SNS.
my space in USA is also the same as these.
and the face-book is expanding globally, however mixi and my space are just their ownings.
mixi user often uses mixi-name, but face-book user has their real name.
those who uses mixi have some perticular points like meeting someone through mixi.
its stupid to make bf or gf through mixi.
i prefer face-book to mixi!!!!!