I am just a beginner player. I started to play piano since 5. And I used to play classical piece.
Recently, I am taking jazz lesson. I have attended 2 lessons already, of course I am still absorbing the theory. Seems that it's a long way to be able to improvise with other instruments.It's a bit difficult to scrap the old learning and embrace the new concept, isn't it?
Anyone can share the experience? or anything about jazz?
I love jazz!!
I am a drummer, and play many different types of music, but jazz is my favorite to play!! Its very free and emotional in my opinion. I don't appreciate big band as much, because its written. but i like listening to it just as much!
I have been playing drums for about 19 years, but i only started playing jazz 4-5 years ago. Im glad i did!!
I'm a pro jazz musician actually...
I feel that its taught wrong...
Teachers make players study pieces like they're studying classical music... In reality that's not how you learn.
I mean, its how you learn to copy other people... but not really speak with your own voice. - - Jazz is really an attitude... and its a study of style... and its a way of expressing yourself while making statements about music you've heard...
I highly recommend a book called THINKING IN JAZZ by Paul Berliner... it is a study of how people learn to "think" as Jazz musicians. Its not a Jazz Improv text... but a brilliant SOCIAL STUDY that all fans and muscicians should read.
My own teacher was Big John Patton, a famous player on the Blue Note label... he began by making me learn how to play the blues and applying different ideas and concepts to the form. He would only let me learn the blues... but taught me a lot... from not speeding up and slowing down, how to form basslines, how to make chords, how to solo... you name it. (He was old fashioned though... If I made a mistake he hit me upside the head... then apologized after the lesson!)
There is one final thing you must understand though:
JAZZ CAN'T BE TAUGHT...
Basic music (technique, theory, rudiments) can...
A true Jazz teacher can only coach...
Learning to play chords and scales and melodies comes BEFORE Jazz...
how to apply them practically is another story...
but a lot of people can't even play simple melodies and they study Jazz... well, how can you comment on a tune when you can't even play it...
Also Jazz is about STYLE... and Dizzy Gillespie himself said "You can't teach style..." - -
Again, you can teach a person to COPY someone else's style... but really you have to know the music and know what you want to learn and go after it.
Hopefully you own a lot of Jazz albums as well as copies of the REAL BOOK... and to plug myself hopefully if you life in Japan you'll be attending some of my shows...
Wow!! Seems I am meeting some great musicians here!!
Yoroshiku~~~~~
Eddy:
I will check out the book, thank you Eddy!!! I guess you are the pianist too. (from the picture in your profile) What kind of stuff you are playing now?
I am in/from Hong Kong. I have checked out the Blue Note Japan last time(2 years ago, probably)when i was in Japan. It was quite impressive (the venue). But expensive too. How's the jazz scene in Japan/Tokyo?
The jazz scene here in HK is quite quiet...
JOJO
19 years in drums....Wow....
I have been playing piano for almost 20 years too.
But still stucking in watching score.
That's why i want to learn how to improf.
So, which musician inspred you ?
My fave is Oscar Peterson,
This is one of my fave song from him
I like everything. Maybe my favourite jazz is by
a guy named Jelly Roll Morton. He was in the
Chicago scene in the 1920s and 30s. Very cool.
Have you heard him? You can download quite a
few of his songs. I think copyright has expired
on them.
JOJO --> If you can play shuffles, boogaloos and swing, I'd like to hear you play. My style is not "modern Jazz", it is "soul Jazz" - - so even though it comes out of the hard bop tradition (still swinging) there's a lot of groove and funkyness in it. (Listen to Jack McDuff!)
- - I think audiences like this approach, but it leads to a lot of conflict with musicians... If you listen to almost any timeless recording there is an element of SIMPLICITY, but most college educated musicians FEAR simplicity... and fight against it.
Actually even if you listen to Art Blakey or for example Miles Davis KIND OF BLUE you hear very simple rhythms behind the players... but most Japanese and younger players like to play in a style that showcases their technique... My goal, however, is to play a type of Jazz that is REAL Jazz but that people who don't even undertand Jazz can appreciate... I feel that the most important thing is that the music has a danceable quality - - Maybe people don't actually dance, but they feel like moving their body. i think most Jazz today is technically REALLY good... but it lacks the danceable quality of the older Jazz... people just sit and listen and say, "Oh, how complicated! I wish I could understand it..." (and people who aren't Jazz OTAKU fall asleep...)
Regarding big band... no doubt, some of it can be very boring, but I hope you can appreciate Buddy Rich... especially his later stuff... http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=5reK-_e-02Qhttp://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=5reK-_e-02Q
This is Arnett Cobb playing with Lionel Hampton. My friend Austin Mitchell was the organist on Arnett Cobb's SMOOTH SAILING album. http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=MRDHAteRF18
テレサ-->
My opinion of Jazz in Japan... The Japanese are the GREATEST collectors and afficianados of Jazz...
There is a vibrant JAM SESSION scene... however, the country needs to go beyond jamming and collecting and make some contributions to the music... I'd say the average Japanese has listened to 1000x more Jazz than the average American... yet Japan hasn't produced its share of *influential legends* (on the other hand, Japan has some of the best studio musicians in the world... if you don't believe me, just watch any of the Rupin III films!)
I love drummers especially ; the great Tony Williams, Buddy Rich, Art Blakey etc
Also like french jazz, Jazz Hip Trio are a favourite of mine...
As for more recent stuff, I'm quite into the new Michael Brecker album "pilgrimage"...
But at the moment I'm really enjoying the avant garde jazz of the 70s, the exploration of fusion etc. Albums like On the Corner, One, Red Clay, Light as a Feather etc...just really hits the spot for me right now.
Oh, honorbale mention for Timo Lassy too - that guy rocks
eddy> i agree with simple can sometimes be best. I did study drums in school for a long time, and i played very complex music and beats... but i still prefer the soul. i would rather sit down with 3 or 4 self taught jazz musicians and just jam for hours its my love!i have no style really... i play what the lead has me play. i used to play in a heavy metal band, and i also played in a wind symphony haha. jazz i like to play ligt, smooth jazz, i really like to play with davis on my headphones. i get really into it.
On a side note, do you really think jazz is strongest here in japan??? the few clubs iv gone too honestly i didnt feel it... they were talented musicians, but i felt it was all like... a facade? there was one club i played in san francisco and after i loved going there everyone who played was great and everyone had their own sound!
I got off topic hahah. I agree about everything you say from an audience perspective, but i have to disagree from a players perspective...
Being in a orchistra and a jazz ensamble, i would almost fall asleep playing... but of course the crowd loves it! but for me not playing what my feelings are saying to me and just going off is not fun for me to play jazz...
I can say its simalar to pop music to me. A good pop band usaly the songs are written for the audeince and their emotions, not the emotions of the artist. but, this is just my opinion.
Of course i respect and love buddy rich, but i would still rather play and listen to cobbs music.
My idol i would have to say is my uncle, he is a jazz drummer, and i love his playing. I also really like cobb, williams ,portnoy, and ginger.
they were talented musicians, but i felt it was all like... a facade? there was one club i played in san francisco and after i loved going there everyone who played was great and everyone had their own sound!
>>
I feel that way too... I stopped teaching because I get over passionate and I HATE when students come to me to study Jazz but refuse to actually listen to it, or don't want to rehearse... My own philosophy: Unless I'm getting paid, I don't want to play music that isn't in my heart. And in general, I made up my mind a long time ago: If I want to be bored and make money, working in an office is better. So I stick to my style.... and starve... but I don't complain (too much.)
Regarding playing for yourself... you can have your cake and eat it too... In my group I like to arrange the basic groove and the begining and ending of the tunes... but you have all the freedom you want in between when its your space... key issue is, if you only want to play for yourself... that's fine, as long as you don't get upset if people don't want to hear you play... My attitude is: I can play my style... If I want to play stuff the audience might not respond to, its o.k. only if I'm willing to realize that its my fault if the audience doesn't want to support me. But that leads to a dilema: What if I want people to appreciate my music? -- So what I do is balance: I might play a "people pleaser" tune... then after that something a bit risky... then I'll play another "people pleaser"... For example, if I am going to play an original tune... I'll surround it by two well known tunes. If I play a bebop tune, I play something funky after it. - - Also, I like to keep solo space short at my gigs... Charlie Parker said if you play more than 4 choruses you're just rehearsing on the bandstand (John Coltrane of course took look solos... but it worked within his concept.) Point is: I think middle ground is important... Lou Donaldson takes this apporach... He'll do a funk tune, then a bebop tune, then a ballad, etc. - - If the tune is working he signals to the band to extend it... otherwise, the solos are short. - - My own experience is that if a tune starts to go beyond 7 or so minutes the audience starts to drift... but if the groove is really strong, you can jam on and on and on.
Regarding San Francisco, a DJ from out there named PETE FALLICO wrote the liner notes to some of my CDs. I've been played on a lot of his shows....
Incidentally I'm a huge FRANK ZAPPA fan... but I think he's a good example of ART vs. ENTERTAINMENT... his tunes were sometimes very experimental, but he used humor to keep the audience focused... Or the tune might be funky or poppish, but the lyrics would be very artistic... When I saw him play he took 20 minute guitar solos... and they were very exciting... but he was very good at setting the mood... for example the tune would begin with some really funny lyrics - - and then the band would launch into a really strange vamp... by the time the solo was over and he went back to the lyrics it was so exciting... But just jamming on and on and on and on and on gets boring after a while...
I ran a Jazz Club in Kita Senju for 2 years (by the way) and literally became crazy from the jam sessions...so now I do like structure... but structure that serves as a vehicle to allow people to express themselves as well.
yeah man jazz is great im a big fan of jazz. I like artists like joe henderson, herbie hancock, wayne shorther, Jaco pastorius and kurt rosenwinkel. i even have
my own little band with some japanese musicans here in New York. i was very surprised to see the influence that jazz has in japan. jazz is everywhere especially in big cities like tokyo.