ログインしてさらにmixiを楽しもう

コメントを投稿して情報交換!
更新通知を受け取って、最新情報をゲット!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆コミュのAbout Women's advance to society...

  • mixiチェック
  • このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
Hi, guys. How are you? I still study Academic writing.
I'm writing about Women's advance to society like work, house keeping, child care, and so on. "The era of women " is a catch phrase heard often these days in Japan, is it true? It means women are advancing in society. The image of women's position is in the home has changed dramatically.

Well, what do you think about this topic? I really wanna hear your opinion and new idea. Please tell me the information.

Thank U for read my topic!!

コメント(22)

hello,
I'm male...so I don't think I'm really qualified to talk here, but it beats working so....

I think it might be hard for the western media, and people in general maybe, to treat women as women rather than 'asian women', 'arabic women' etc...
From my point of view I often hear a lot of non-japanese talk about how 'Japanese women' are very domesticated, and for that matter asian women in general....I think it's a kind of myth, maybe at some time based on fact, but greatly over played by the western media...and fueled by hollywood movies.
When China had it's social revolution for instance a lot of bad things happened, but one good thing was that the once subjugated chinese women were given the same working rights as the men...you can still see heroic 'worker women' idolised in Chinese propaganda...
With regards to Japan, I would still say there's a "glass ceiling" in the workplace for women...but this is still true in my home country also - so I don't think we could single out Japan. I've met female graphic designers who have way more qualifications than me but can not get access to the clients I get access to. And I don't think these decisions are based on any serious critereon.
I think if there was ever an "era of women" it was the 19th century in the west, I couldn't really comment for asia - but I'd say it's yet to come...
I guess the phrase "The era of Women" is ultimately a media tool (thought up by men probably) to pacify, and pretend that we have a fair society. From what I've seen in my own country, over here, and the other places I've been, I'd say men are in no way prepared to hand over any serious reigns of power to women, and I'd like to ask if women even want them in the first place....
I believe it is a good thing in general that women are being treated more fairly these days. It's high time we stopped looking at women solely as "housewives" or child-rearers. There's no place for sexism in the modern society... at least in my book.

As for Japan, I feel as though they've come a long way but still have a lot to do to become a truly equal society for men and women. AFAIK, women are still severely underpaid compared to their male counterparts. They don't get paid maternity leaves. They're expected to quit their jobs once they get married. Those who decide to keep working are expected to do all the house chores while their husbands sit in the couch watching TV.

At least that's the Japan that I recall. I hope my perception is outdated, but I somehow doubt it...
If you study Susan Sontag, this would be interesting.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcfour/audiointerviews/profilepages/sontags1.shtml
I feel not equal society for man and women in Japan yet.
Japan society should be doing something for working mothers or will be mothers.
For example, many company should build more work share, Part-timer welfare program, child care institution and so on for working women.

In fact, I'm mothe too. I always feeling difficult to change the job.
because I can't help to continue for a work while bringing up my children.
my husband is too busy to help me.

I'm really sorry about its my complaint.
...: I think it's hard for western guys like us to understand what it's really like for women in Japan. From what I've heard things *are* changing, but there is still not equality in any sense. I agree that there is not real equality in the west either, but the women's liberation movement of the 1970's changed a lot and Japan has not had an equivalent movement to really force the issue.

One thing about the United States is that while there still isn't true equality, there is an attitude that came from the women's lib movement that there should be *no* gender differences in anything. The ideal is that men and women should always be treated the same in everything, including in how people dress, how people wear their hair, how people talk, etc. I actually think this is a *bad* thing for women here, because it seems like what women have decided in this country is that the way to get ahead in life is to act like men. I think it actually demeans women. I think it's common sense that there are differences between men and women - physical differences, differences in how we think about the world, etc. and we shouldn't try to hide those differences and act like both sexes are exactly the same. That's really got nothing to do with having an equal chance for an office job or being CEO of a company. There's no reason why women should have to act like men to get good jobs.

So I actually hope that women in Japan don't decide the same course of action, that the way for them to improve their lives is to just start acting like men all the time. It seems to me that a better way would be for women to force a change on the male culture in truly accepting and respecting who they are as women. It's the mens' problem in acting like assholes that's causing things to be bad for women in Japan; it's not the womens' fault in acting like women. Both men and women should be true to who they are, but it's up to men to change their attitudes about women.
Long time no see!!

Thank you for your opinion. I'm glad to hear your new ideas and opinion!!

I will compare Japanese women's position with American women's one. I have many infomation about Japanese one, but I do not know American condition about women's position like housekeeping, work outside the home, and so on.

If you know book or cites, please tell me.

Thank you!!
One big difference that I see between the Japanese and U.S. societies about women is that the U.S. recognizes the ongoing inequality and tries to address the problem in many ways, ranging from creating laws to raising awareness among both men and women. What I often see in Japan, OTOH, is the attitude that hides the problem and behaves as if everything was fine. It's not just about sex discrimination. I often run into Japanese guys who accuse the U.S. of condoning racial discrimnation while being totally ignorant of their own racial issues such as the Ainu and the Japanese-Koreans.

The first step to take is to be aware of the problem and face it instead of trying to cover it up.

>> my husband is too busy to help me.

This is another problem with the Japanese society. Men are usually expected to work into the night, which leaves them little time to help out their spouses.
>> But then, I cannot guarantee that I am not gonna
>> be quitting my job when I am married...so....it's
>> also a gamble for a company to hire a girl

That is based upon the old assumption that you are supposed to work for one employer for life. I hear it's changing in Japan, so hopefully it will give female workers more freedom and less restrictions. :)
and what the crack are you talking about. this topic is just waaay 90s(either japanese or the u.s yuppies era).

oh i don't see what you call "women's advance" in utah land. please don't just generalize by watching those people on wall street.

if you are talented or got something, then you are it. and vice versa, if you are not, hell, you know what i mean. the affirmitive action exists for that and it's not perfect. hey, what the, reverse discrimination...? is that what every white man faces?

take look at offices in nyc for instance. do you see black or latino(a) women as much as you do on the streets? ha, it hasn't changed much since it was introduced in mid 60s.

what i am traying to say is that don't just pick on the japanese society when you write the school paper. but ayu, if this paper is argument paper, it's ok to dis it as much as you want, if not, i wouldn't recommend it.

although when it comes right down to the business talk, i extremelly abominate the japanese resume. what's the picture for anyway?
I totally agree with Jeff. I think that there must be a equality between men and women to certain extent but at the same time men and women have different physical appearence also psychological fact that men and women express their emotion differently. So i think that there is something men can do but women cannot do as much as men do, vice versa. Just think about the time how it used to be in traditional family back then compare to modern family. I believe that the way function in the family in the past was better than today. What do you all think about it?
meg-san,

I'm not sure I understand what you mean by "the time how it used to be in traditional family back then compare to modern family." What is the traditional family by your definition? What is different now than that?
The female gender has been and is still expanding on the possibilities of what they can and will do in the work force. Of course there are the traditional females who enjoy being the typical housewife but there are also females who enjoy being out in the work force. Whatever they do is due to thier choice, its not like in the past where females didn't have the option to do whatever they wanted to do but now since they do, I feel they don't have the luxury to blame anyone on where they are at. Im sure there are nicks and cracks where females are restricted in alot of areas that im not familiar with but im sure that will change with time and the role of the female gender is expanding little by little.
ヘンリー and others...

How many female doctors do you see in Japan? (I'll tell you: 14% of Japanese doctors are women). Do you think this is because they don't want to be doctors? Do you think it's because they don't have the mental capacity for it? How can you explain this while still arguing that women can do "whatever they want"?

How can you explain the presence of female-only train cars on the subway if you don't believe there is still sexism in Japan?

There is still quite a lot of sexism and inequality in Japan, both subtle and not so subtle. Women are "encouraged" to go into certain professions and not others. In daily life, they are victims of various forms of harassment that would be completely unacceptable in other countries, even among men.

Things are changing - there are more female medical school graduates now than there used to be, for example, but it's still nowhere close to equal.

だいはど was right when he said the first step in fixing the problem is acknowledging that there is a problem. You can't just look at a slight improvement in one area and say "oh, that's it, there's no problem anymore". This is a big issue that's been part of Japan's culture for thousands of years and it's not going to change overnight.

(Please don't misunderstand - read my earlier post and you'll see that I'm not someone who thinks Japan should be exactly like the west. It needs to find its own solutions to its problems. But this *is* still a problem.)
I miss working at an office among wonderful co-workers trying to achieve common goals such as sales or marketing. But if I were asked to leave my kids and go back to work during the day, it will kill me. Raising and taking care of children is such a precious experience. I can't give it up. Kids grow every minute. Kids are as bright as diamonds. They teach you the true beauty. I believe many women feel the same as I do, just naturally. It is women's gift to nurse and comfort as well as to protect children as a mother, at least during age of 0-4 or 5. Even my 6 year old son needs me to baby him when he feels weak. I wouldn't wanna miss these once-in-life-time moments. As a home maker, my job is not only taking care of children but to keep the house clean, to cook, and to manage our family budget. These take up a lot of my time, actually almost my whole day, and I don't really have time to have a job now. So that's my case. I used to desire to work in an office again whenever my kids are independant, but right now I can't really think of it. Raising small kids only takes up 10 to 15 years of my long life (planning to have another kid at this point...), and I'm sure my kids need someone to be with them all the time and I wanna be the one. What I'm saying is that advancing in society doesn't appeal to me while raising kids as this is a precious time...
↑thanks kew! you answered my question...

p/s there's a lot of guys (including me) posting on this topic aren't there.....is that wierd...or what...I dunno...anyway.....
I am sorry that I didn't explain enough but what I meant by traditional family is that there are father, mother and their children in the family and each parent has his/her own role that his/her is responsible for taking care of his/her children and family. Does it make sense to you, Daihado?
meg-san,

Thanks for the reply. Yes, it makes sense. I'd argue that each parent having his/her own roles does not mean they have to do everything separately. For instance, is the mother supposed to raise children on her own while the father earns money for the family on his own?

The ideal married couple that I envision is one where both partners are independent and capable of making their own decisions, yet are willing to work together to make their married life a happy one. There are a lot of different ways to achieve the goal. Some couples may choose to do what you call the traditional role assignment. Others may choose to share every task. The important thing is that they are both comfortable with the decisions and leave room for changes/improvement if necessary, no matter what those decisions are.
In response to Jeff, Well first of all im not in any way familiar with the japanese society especially because i have never lived there in my life. Of course i've been there to visit my relatives but i have no knowledge of what the situations are over there. I practically assumed the ratios would be similar in japan as in america. But as i was thinkin that, i remembered that the sexual harassment law or whatever they enacted to put those offenders away just got put in place while america was over that for a decent amount of time. So Japan is in a way behind where america is possibly a lil more diverse and equal than THAN the other countries are. America on the other hand, i still feel and will not change my thoughts where if one wants to be a (for an example that you put forth) doctor, I feel that there are other factors other than the harrassments and restrictions that females are presented in trying to go into the profession. Many have the dream to become mothers of a child(get married etc etc) that obviously take much of their time from their alternate dream of becoming a "doctor" and limits their capabilities. This is thier choice, there are females that choose not to go into that direction and focus more on their professions. Of course there are jobs in politics and many more that i for sure don't know that aren't open to females as much it is to men but still, its still opening up. Its a process, and the process will only grow when they choose to go in that direction.

ログインすると、残り4件のコメントが見れるよ

mixiユーザー
ログインしてコメントしよう!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆ 更新情報

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆のメンバーはこんなコミュニティにも参加しています

星印の数は、共通して参加しているメンバーが多いほど増えます。