experience>education
education is usefull to make foundation of languages but without experience it won't be the real one.languages don't live only in the books.
It depends on what it is you want to do. There are some carreer feilds where more training is demonstrably better for you (like oh, say education) , and others where a Ph.D would just be taking up space on the wall (Auto Mechanics for example) so it really depends on what you want to do.
That being said, in general the more schooling you have the more you'll get paid. A 4-year degree increases your earning potential across the board by almost a factor of ten.
I don't think you can separate the concepts of learning and skill (education/experience) into an inside or outside the classroom concept. "Book and street" are too intertwined and to differentiate. What you learn and experience inside a class has multiple impacts on life and learning outside the class and vice versa.
I would like to see any comments that capably separate these ideas though, because I can see where you are coming from. I.E. Learning languages..
dont separate them, dont try to decide which is more important because both are important.
people who believes one's experience is everything are so boring and often ignorant of the rest of his/her world. education is a tool to live wiser, little more practical and make the most of what you learn from experiences.
It all depends what you are doing. Think about it like this when you get out of college you already have experince working in the general field however there is still time to sharpen your skills. Also companies might want to get you fresh out of college to easily work you in since you don't have anything your used to. At least for my field, Vehicle Research and Design, most companies want you fresh out so they can easly throw you in to the mix. Besides at my college we already have the experince that all companies are looking for :-P Go Western Washington VRI! haha. Well in the end its like this. Education is experince, you just need to know how to present it AS experince at the interview. Remember some employers love fresh faces and recruits.
I agree with Guchi and others. I don't think it's possible to separate "education" and "experience" black-and-white. A lot of how well you do in the real world depends upon how you learn and adapt new things. For me, I learned a lot more in the first three months from my job than in the two years of class work in Computer Science. That said, I don't think I'd have been able to learn much at all if it weren't for my education.
hahaha. didn't you guys see that one season of "the apprentice" where they did "book smart" vs. "street smart"? hahahaha. book smart won that one, but that's irrelevant. i think that both are very important, but if i had to choose between or the other, i would choose book smarts. the stuff in textbooks is usually based off of many people's previous experience right? so if you were to start off, let's say starting a business, and you didn't go to school for it, you will probably learn many things about business, but only after many mistakes and failures (not to mention a long time). if you were to take a class, you would learn many things about business in a fraction of the time, without having to go through the same thing that the other person who didn't get an education. but the good thing about starting on "the street" so to speak is that it makes you tougher.
but like i said, both are important, but i think that "book smarts" takes the cake.
i think both of them are certainly significant and i cacnnot separate them, really...
education is the opportunity to expand knowledge, serch for my own interest in various studying categories, and prepare for working in a society, but experience is also the good chance to develop an capability of managing jobs and build confidence.
education gets you in the door, experience is what gets you paid. and by experience i am assuming good experience.
so both are important but at different stages in your acreer. as time goes on your educational credentials are meaningless. but in the beginning, it will go a long way towards getting a good job.
"Both are important but at different stages in your acreer. as time goes on your educational credentials are meaningless. but in the beginning, it will go a long way towards getting a good job."
Education is like something that helps you to enter a gate of the world, but experience is like something that helps you to servive in that world.
I always see many people without any degree can work more efficiently than others who got high educations. But they always find that educational degree is an obtacle for them to get a good job. Why most of employers always judge people by their educational background? I know that education background is something that they can prove easily than other qualifications, but why most of them never give a chance for those talented and experienced person without good education background?
They're both important! For example, language. I am trying to learn the Japanese language, and education (Japanese classes) teach the basics and proper grammar and vocabulary, but experience is what seals it in. That is, using it daily is what helps me speak more fluently and easily.
> "Education is like something that helps you to enter a gate of the world, but experience is like something that helps you to servive in that world. "
At a certain point, though, experience and education are the same thing. You never stop learning. So I would say education continues to be important forever, while experience is *only* important later in life.
For example, I work for a TV station. I got the job both because I went to film school and because I had experience doing the particular kind of work I'd be doing. So both were important. But as I'm working, I'm continuing to learn about TV and film production. It's experience but it's also part of my education, and my knowing these things (not just doing them, but knowing the processes) will help me both at this job and potentially at any future job.
So both are important, but I think education might be a little more important.
This might be extreme opinion, but I think experience is much more important than education, if he/she is in typical company, knowlegde is very important and knowledge would come from education but based on my experience, most of my friends don't have high education but they have firm thought and can think quickly everything about their decision. and more than anything else, they are funny, cause its from their fresh experience on their zigzag life.
I can say people who has lots experience is stronger at the hard condition than who just have education.
but I can also say we need education to earn much more experiences...
i think, i THINK, this is almost like one of the issues that the japanese government is going through right now. they're debating on whether to change a few parts of the fundamental law of education (?) i think... honesltly, im not at all informed about this but, its whether to introduce the words patriotism or not on it. okay some one correct me if im wrong i might be saying bullshit here.
anyway in my opinion to love or feel part of one's country has nothing to do with school. im not saying what you learn at school isnt important, its just that when they grade you, it shouldnt be based on what you've learned from text books etc...
plus, this is so banal, but national wise, almost everyone has the same education at least til about 14 years old, personal experiences builds up the indentity, i think... but thats all i could think of
and i just noticed that i havent answered the question, which is more important? i do not know
I THINK often people who have gone to uni are useless but people with a lot of experience but haven't graduated from uni will be more useful.
maybe not in japan but in england, loads of people with experience have highly paid jobs.
I think both is important. But the point is these cannot mean itself without each other.
sometimes I hear people go abroad without leraning anything about grammar and they say it is much more better to get English than studying in Japan.
I think it's wrong. Without studying grammar, it's really hard to spreak English fruently. I don't know exuctly
how long they would stay, but even how long terms they y would, i think it is not enough, it would take more time.
But i don't say only grammar can make people a good speaker. if they study grammar as hard as they can, without speaking time, they cannot be one.
What i want to say is, education make people English readers or writters and experience make them speakers.
First of all, I noticed that education is defined less clearly, reading through what people wrote about them. I guess this is because education is not the opposite word against experience. The word is "knowledge." Education can be a conbination of experience and knowledge in some meaning. We can, therefore, discuss experience and knowledge, like practice and theory.
However, I enjoyed reading what people wrote and don't want to make a suggestion only to make it discussion or debate stuff. So, let me simply write about my experience and opinion.
I love traveling. I traveled around America and Southeast Asia. Before I left Japan, I studied English and had some knowledge about the cities and the history of the countries. Thank to them, I could talk with people living there and enjoy sightseeing this and that. Without knowing their language or backgrounds, I don't think I could enjoy it so much.
On the other hand, I can have more fun with the guidebooks of my next destination, because I have some experiences in traveling. I couldn't draft my plans for the first time like this. Now I can easily imagine what the next travel is going to be like. Experience gives you imagination and inspiration.
Both of experience and education made me enjoy traveling. You can't take only one from the two. Which is "more" important depends on what you want to do. You can arrange how much importance you will put on one and the other based on your purpose. To be a mathematician you will need to learn a lot of theories and a bit of experience, but you will need more practice to be a swimmer than swimming theories. It depends.
In the long run, both are essential. I took five years of Italian but can hardly do anything with it because I never took what I learned out of the classroom. (If I learned anything at all...heh heh!)
Jeez. It's a tough call...maybe I'd give experience the edge. Because you can learn as you do, whereas when you are sitting in the classroom the information is being given to you.
I think experience is most important, BECAUSE, although it is NICE to have an education, people all over the world who have not had one are still surviving. These survival tips cannot be taught in a book, they must be experienced.
Education is a nice bonus in my opinion...
from my experience, hahah,
i do think experience is very important but, like mentioned earlier, if you start of without education, it can be hard to put things together. so i think that constant experience from day 1 is good, cuz it allows you to learn faster. but i think at least the foundations should be taught as it makes your learning speed faster.
also think about how much more of a language you learn when you go study abroad.
you know, reading stories and watching movies are kind of experience. we can not live others life, life is too short to understand stranger's life and feelings all over the world. so then, we read books, watch movies to experience someone else's life. how much you are experienced in various field, time is limited. there are many things you can never know by yourself out there.
I say people who think experience is the most and education is less important are boring because, people who think ones real experience is everything know only one story and think it is everything.