ログインしてさらにmixiを楽しもう

コメントを投稿して情報交換!
更新通知を受け取って、最新情報をゲット!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆コミュのThe Death Penalty

  • mixiチェック
  • このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
Hi!! I'm a third year student at university. Let's thinking about death penalty.

It is oblished in Japan. What do you think about it?? Are you agree, or disagree?? And why do you think so?
I think it should not be oblished. Because if it's oblished, the crime will more increase. So, the world will change more badly.

Please tell me your opinion. Thank you for reading my poor English.

コメント(132)

92:
I absolutly agree. Its dirty justice in my opinion. It means that people are not for it because they belive its just or fair or better for society. It means they are for it because they belive that they will be full of hatred and spite when their loved ones die.

> statistically speaking four of them believe in astrology
But there are also many christians in america and one of the 10 commandments says "you shall not kill" so I think no christian will agree with the Death Penaltiy, right?ウインク Turn the other cheek and forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive them that trespass against us, all that stuff.
I'm totally for it for extreme crimes such as murder and child rape. That being said, I think the system needs to be reformed because too many innocents are put to death. I think it should be reserved for cases where hard, solid, indisputable evidence is present.

I see it this way; if someone kills and rapes all my loved ones, I'm either going to let the state put them to death, or I'll kill them myself. I'd rather not be punished for having everything taken from me.
デイブ (#94)

>> if someone kills and rapes all my loved ones, I'm either going to let the state
>> put them to death, or I'll kill them myself.

I understand where you're coming from, but that is (as you probably know) a very dangerous mindset. Revenge is not an accepted concept in today's criminal laws. Besides, I'm pretty sure your loved ones would NOT want you to become a killer yourself.
#76

No.....

Why the hell do I need to pay for their Cable TV? Their Library's, their computers, their chaplains, their study material, any of that crap? Why do i need to pay for them to get good quality food?

Huh? Why? cause it's human? screw that...

I work hard for my money, and follow the laws....

Why should it go to them to make their lives EASIER in prison after they just destroyed peoples lives? Huh? That's just stupid...

I just can't agree with it, nor will I ever agree with it...
97: ウィール

I guess the question is, where do you draw the line? You pay to
keep carjackers in prison, you pay to keep muggers in prison, you
pay to keep people who drive dangerously in prison. Should we
kill them all?
What about doctors who administers a lethal dose of barbiturate to
a patient who is in terrible pain? What about policemen who shoot
a guy who is pulling out his ID which the policeman demanded
he do.
What about mentally ill people who murder while in a paranoid
delusion?
So where do you draw the line??
93 Kimi
> But there are also many christians in america and one of the 10 commandments says "you shall not kill" so I think no christian will agree with the Death Penaltiy, right?


Ah, America, land of paradox. ボケーっとした顔
One of the problems I see, is that China regularly execute dissidents
and most people are rightly outraged. The Talib would shoot women
for educating girls, Iran executes Christians for proselytizing. Somalia
executes women for adultery...strangely not men.
What these countries are doing they are doing according to their law.
If you asked the average person on the street in these countries they
would say the person deserved their punishment.
When your average American or Japanese person says they support
the death penalty I wonder if they would say they support it in these
cases, or just in cases where their rules about civil society have been
broken.
I see a lot of posts arguing that crime would increase if the death penalty was abolished. Although I am not an expert, I find that hard to believe. The US has the death penalty, but crime rates are much higher than in Europe, where the death penalty was abolished long ago. High crime rates are more likely to be caused by social inequality, desperation, and perhaps a society which drives people crazy.

Also, how do you on one hand say that killing is wrong, and then on the other hand kill? We are going to kill you, because you killed, and that's wrong. I fail to see the logic of this argument.
Sorry, Im going to drop from the thread... cause the things I want to say will probably really piss some people off.. So I am going to stop before that happens.

peace!
ウィール (#103)

I don't think you need to stay away. It is a given that "tastes differ." It would be rather totalitarian to allow for only certain opinions, and I don't think anybody wants that.

I do believe that death penalty should be abolished altogether, but that's not to say I refuse to listen to those who disagree with me.
Genesis, I had trouble following you point but don't worry about it. Supporting the death penalty is another way for us to remember that we have inherited freedom and that freedom CAN be taken away.
Pancho (#106)

Care to elaborate on your logic? Why do we need the death penalty in order to remember that freedom can be taken away?
Me? I agree with the death penalty. Sometimes, life sucks. And yes I do realize, "what if it happens to you?" Well, I guess I shouldn't have been fuckin' up then, huh? Seriously, who's gonna miss a few people if they die after killing someone who may not have deserved it?

Yes, I have suffered the loss of someone to death and got over it a week later at the age of 11. BUT! People die. That's what we do as living things. Still, I will have to admit that I tend to be a lot more apathetic than the people who surround me. Death is a part of life, whether premature or otherwise. Sometimes, death is the answer (no, I'm not an emo chick).
108 Empress Leo

Hehe, sure.. what's the big deal about a little unwarranted killing here and there, when life's so overrated? I'm reminded of the following from Bierce:

"Life's not worth living, and that's the truth,"
Carelessly caroled the golden youth.
In manhood still he maintained that view
And held it more strongly the older he grew.
When kicked by a jackass at eighty-three,
"Go fetch me a surgeon at once!" cried he.
#98 #100 Ian.... No one is suggesting that people be killed for lower level crimes that don`t result in the intentional death of the victims. Accidental death and other cases will be judged case by case. No one is going to agree that someone should die for the reasons you stated. And as was also mentioned we have the capability of using DNA testing now and that will help a lot to keep the innocent from being put to death by mistake. That is about all we can do and it has to be good enough.

#102 "I see a lot of posts arguing that crime would increase if the death penalty was abolished. Although I am not an expert, I find that hard to believe." First lets just settle it right now... Most
of us that agree to the death penalty don`t give a crap about the effect it might have on the crime rate.. we just want to see the assholes pay for their crimes of Murder with their own lives and to get them off the books and out of the society for good. The crime rate is irrelevant.
TokyoOG
>> No one is suggesting that people be killed for lower
>> level crimes that don`t result in the intentional death
>> of the victims.

The examples I was using weren't very well thought
through. I have seen people killed, both state sanctioned
and what is usually referred to as extra-judicial. That
very much effects my position.

If I can use the U.S. as a case in point, an African American
is many times more likely to receive the death penalty
than a white American for similar crimes. I would argue
that even if you support the death penalty in theory
you should oppose it because of how it is applied.

111:
>And as was also mentioned we have the capability of using DNA testing now and that will help a >lot to keep the innocent from being put to death by mistake
>That is about all we can do and it has to be good enough.

Tough luck for the inocents and their families. They are not allowed to kill the Judges that sentenced their loved ones to death but theres always a bit of colleteral damage.
Thankfully I'm white and thus very unlikely to be killed if I were in the States. Neither by the government nor by mobsters.わーい(嬉しい顔)
#112
"I would argue that even if you support the death penalty in theory
you should oppose it because of how it is applied. " Why don`t we just take more steps to
ensure that the Death Penalty is applied correctly? I just don`t agree that every criminal is
capable of being rehabilitated. And in some extreme cases the Death Penalty is appropriate.
If the people we have now in place can not correctly enforce the laws we simply need to replace them with people who can. We can`t decide not to live on this earth... so we need to fix the problems. And letting Charles Manson type criminals escape the death penalty is crazy.
TokyoOG (#114)

>> I just don`t agree that every criminal is capable of being rehabilitated.

We probably have to agree to disagree on this. I firmly believe that every single person should be given a chance. I'm glad I'm not the only one. The countries that have abolished the death penalty AND do not have "life in prison with no parole" essentially agree with me.
TOG, you just aren't taking the "policy" view of this stuff. I don't think every criminal can be rehabilitated either - but I also don't think some government employee should get to decide which ones can and which ones can't. In other words, it's not a question of how the world ought to be, it's a question of what we do and don't allow the government to do to people.
114:
I am a bit reminded of a guy i once knew who thought communism was great. We basically disagreed how humans work. He thought humans could be totaly selfless and everyone could see why A or B was bad for him but better for society as a whole so no government would be needed any more because everyone would think the same thing about everything after all. In essence he thought humans could be flawless and uniform.

I think its the same here. A judge will never be perfect, a code of law will always be flawed. Its safer to not let flawed concepts decide over matters of - literally - life and death.

>We can`t decide not to live on this earth... so we need to fix the problems.
I agree.
One of the myriad problems with the death penalty is it's always
political. Politicians have agendas and the death penalty sends a
certain message to voters which doesn't do them any harm.

I would add that humans have prejudices, lawyers and judges do
their best to suppress them and most of them succeed, but juries
are just people off the street who listen to shock radio, watch
fox news and think Saddam Hussein bank-rolled 9/11.

I do agree that some criminals are beyond rehabilitation. There
is a convicted pedophile in Australia who re-offended 3 days
after being released from prison. As far as I know he has never
expressed any remorse, and actually blamed to victims for his
being in prison. He is now in prison with a special class of sentence
which allows for indefinite detention. He will never be released
from prison.
だいはド(107) what's to explain? Whenever we receive any sort of punishment for any sort of crime, we are reminded that our liberties can be taken away. What was that line from the XXX movie about a song from the Vandals? Something like, "if you think America is a free country try walking into a deli and urinating on the cheese" or something along those lines.

Bottom line, if the crime fits the punishment, let the punishment stand. Yes I believe in the death penalty as a punishment to be plied. No I would never impose it myself, but you should have the right to enforce it when you deem proper.
#115 "The countries that have abolished the death penalty AND do not have "life in prison with no parole" essentially agree with me." Just because they agree with you doesn`t mean that it is the right decision. There are also many other countries and people that obviously disagree with you and them as well.

#117 "A judge will never be perfect, a code of law will always be flawed. " That is why we need more than one level of procedures. One to check the other to keep things kosher. No one judge or jury should have absolute power. I am talking about crimes where there is "no doubt" that the criminal is guilty. Like the guy that ran his truck into a crowed cross walk and then got out the truck and started killing the people that came to help. He was caught on film! Red handed! And he later admitted planing to kill even more people but he couldn`t get a larger truck! And some of you want to insist that this guy should be spared? Sorry.. not me. As long as the person is not totally, certifiably, insane they should hang and life goes on for the rest of the world without the need to worry about being killed by that person.

#118 "He is now in prison with a special class of sentence
which allows for indefinite detention. He will never be released
from prison. " If he will never be released why waste money carrying for him
that some very needy aboriginal family could use. Or some worthy student could use for their studies? Some criminals are obvious losers that could care less about their own lives or the lives of their victims. This is when the Death Penalty is appropriate in my opinion flawed system and all.
I feel assured that those who advocate death penalty and criticize use of tax money for life imprisonment without parole will not hesitate to demonstrate their commitment by volunteering as pro bono executioners.
Many thanks :-)
When used the right way, the death penalty is useful. Why pay for evil doers with no remorse when we won't miss them in the end? There are lots of people in jail who will never reform, have no remorse and don't even cooperate with the people who DO want to help them. Kill them. Seriously. There are a LOT of wrongful deaths in the world. But, I also feel there are a lot of right one when the hand is played correctly. If a man's wife is killed, her husband should not go out and find the killer to return the favor. But if/when he's caught, depending on HOW the murder was done, for what reason, etc, etc...he should either be put in prison or off'd. Life IS worth living. But some people fuck up a little too bad for me to give a shit whether or not they live or die. I'm not saying that if someone did something really bad, it's an automatic 'F', to me, it always depends on many factors before coming to a solution. I support the death penalty as being one of those options as a solution. One of the many options. It's only one.
Pancho #(119)

>> Whenever we receive any sort of punishment for any sort of crime,
>> we are reminded that our liberties can be taken away.

I agree with you on this. I just didn't know whether you meant "only the death penalty" would take away one's freedom.

Now that I know where you stand, the only thing that seems to separate us is the idea the death penalty can be a proper punishment. How is it any more proper, in your opinion, than, say, locking up the criminal for life?
From what I understand, the taxpayers pay to keep prisoners imprisoned (unless there's something I'm missing, which could very well be the case because I don't follow politics and the like so well). He's not doing anything in prison forever but taking up more space. Just rotting away. What's the point? Out of sight, out of mind. If they are going to be there forever without an ounce of contribution or even a slight chance at society, why stick around? This doesn't go for all bad crimes, of course. Some people should be locked up for a long period of time for whatever reason, get paroled, whatever. But, like I said, I'm not a very sensitive person. I don't really even like to give children more than two chances to mess something up or disobey for dealing with consequences. If I make my niece cry after telling her once or twice not to do something, she can go to her room and cry because I can't hear the TV/music/study/etc. Go away and feel bad over their. Come back when you're done. I think extreme punishment is justice to a certain extent. I just really believe that there are SOME people in this world that we could do without. Honestly, am I gonna care if a non-remorseful serial rapist/killer/etc leaves this world? Nope. It's like I tell some people when they are surprised at certain consequences due to their own stupid actions: "You knew the job was dangerous when you signed up."
>>He's not doing anything in prison forever but taking up more space. Just rotting away. What's the point?

In pure logical principle, I agree but you have to remember that many
people are wrongly accused and freed later.

Until a justice system can find with 100% certainty with 0% error
that a person is guilty (impossible), the death penalty should not
exist. Even if it saves just one person wrongly accused, we as
a society should pay to keep people imprisoned.

Once you put an innocent man to death, there is no turning back.

#125 "Until a justice system can find with 100% certainty with 0% error
that a person is guilty (impossible), the death penalty should not
exist." WTF are you talking about ? Ever heard of eye witnesses ? DNA? Video Tape?
You don`t believe your own eyes when you see a crime taking place on a security camera at a store? We all said to be guilty without a doubt required evidence like this!!! So it is not impossible to know without a doubt that the person is guilty. Unless of course you are blind and can`t see the evidence. In which case you will not be chosen to be on the jury. Stop arguing for the sake of arguing.
126 TokyoOG
> Ever heard of eye witnesses ? DNA? Video Tape?
You don`t believe your own eyes when you see a crime taking place on a security camera at a store? We all said to be guilty without a doubt required evidence like this!!!


You're not thinking your arguments through. DNA testing and video can prove *who* committed a crime, but that's not the only factor in play. Applying the death penalty also depends on the circumstances and motives and so on, and judging those things is still a subjective decision made by subjective people.

And that's why, even with DNA testing, we still mostly execute black people, and presumably will keep doing so for the foreseeable future. You seem to be fine with that, which mystifies me.
Incidentally, I'm curious. All those here that support the death penalty agree, I think, that inevitably an innocent person will sooner or later be executed. Given that certainty, I wonder: what is your value of "N", as described below?
http://www.law.ucla.edu/volokh/guilty.htm
118:
>> He is now in prison with a special class of sentence
>> which allows for indefinite detention. He will never be
>> released
120:
>> If he will never be released why waste money caring
>> for him

I guess there are 2 points to make. Countries which
oppose the death penalty do so because they consider
it cruel and unusual. It's as simple as that.

The second point is not an argument against the death
penalty but saving money is sometimes raised by advocates
of the death penalty.
It costs about $60,000 per year to maintain a prisoner in
a maximum security prison. That can go up to about
$90,000 per year in some cases and even higher in very
rare cases.
Even using the figure of $90,000, it is still going to cost
less to detain him for 40 years than the average cost of
getting a prisoner to execution.
TokyoOG,

You think the crime rate is irrelevant, but many people on this forum seemed to worry that crime rates would increase if the death penalty was abolished. I personally don't think that crime rates are relevant to this discussion, but at least people shouldn't be think that the death penalty acts as a deterrent.

I can think of many much better arguments against the death penalty than the crime rate issue, but I doubt they would make you change your mind.


Tokyo OG

First of all, thanks for your unnecessarily combative tone.

Secondly, go get hooked on phonics and re-read what I wrote.

Third, google "overturned murder convictions" and get back to me.
Here I'll get you started.
http://partners.nytimes.com/library/national/061200death-penalty.html


If you are ok with taking the chances of killing an innocent
person, go ahead. I'll be voting against the death penalty
every time.
It is wrong to give up on a system because we can`t seem to get honest people to run it properly.
I am all for allowing the defendants to appeal their rulings. But in the end, if they are found guilty without a doubt, and the crime warrants it, they should get the Death Penalty. I don`t believe that we ( humans) are not capable of conducting a fair trial. That is why I said we have to be sure
and make improvements in the system. I don`t know where most of you come from or have been exposed to, but like it or not, there is a very dark side to some people. Race doesn`t matter. It`s just human nature at it`s worse. I have seen it. And that is why I feel the way I do about the Death Penalty. And Yes! I could throw the switch or push the button myself and get a good nights
sleep afterwards. The fact that most of you can`t mystifies me. It`s a dirty job, but somebody`s got to do it.

ログインすると、残り96件のコメントが見れるよ

mixiユーザー
ログインしてコメントしよう!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆ 更新情報

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆のメンバーはこんなコミュニティにも参加しています

星印の数は、共通して参加しているメンバーが多いほど増えます。