ログインしてさらにmixiを楽しもう

コメントを投稿して情報交換!
更新通知を受け取って、最新情報をゲット!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆コミュのAsian-Americans?

  • mixiチェック
  • このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
This is a question to my fellow Asians. Non-Asians are of course welcome to participate too, if you have interest in this issue. You have probably heard of the term "Asian-American" before. It is commonly used in the media, in education and in your daily life as well. I don't know how you feel about this but I think this term is sometimes being used in a discriminatory way. Articles in publications such as "Asian Week" often address "Asian-Americans" but it makes me feel that non-American Asians are being excluded. No offense, but what's so special about being an "Asian-American"? I have never heard the term "Asian-Canadian" or "Asian-European" in any publication. There is a newspaper called "Asian Pacifc Post" in Canada, but Asians are simply referred to as "Asians" and not some hyphenated names. What's up with that?

コメント(113)

well if china is not pure, then who is pure?

eskimos?

han chinese...you mean mr. han & his family from Enter the Dragon?

what about the Mongolians?

are they pure?

if no one is pure...then it doesn't matter if there is any race...we are all mixed...

yeah...try telling it to the white folk...

now...UK & Asian/Oriental...

no thoughts on it...it's foreign to me...

I just know, when I look in the mirror...I have slanted eyes...and I don't have white skin...

I don't consider myself Asian...I consider myself OTHER...or MIXED...

I like screwing up the census...

so, unless the government wants to put a stamp on my forehead...

I am OTHER...

but IF I ever go to the UK...I will tell them I am OTHER...

or if I feel nice...ORIENTAL...

cuz I have never been to India, Pakistan, Bangaladesh, etc...
Han is the name of the ethnic group that most Chinese people belong to.

However, there's over a hundred different ethnic groups in China, because of the size of the country. Officially, 56 of them are recognized by the government, and most have their own culture and language, such as the Yao or Tibetans.

As for the notion of "racial purity", as Guchi said, science has shown it's a myth. The larger reasons of why people from the same ethnic group tend to intermarry are culture and language.
I like the guy from Enter the Dragon...

maybe he's related to the Han clan...

but within 100 years...

the Chinese will be taking over the world...

whether purity or not...everyone will have slanted eyes...and yellow pigmentation...

now, will dictatorship/communism control the world, or will the Chinese people revolt and use the Western world's Capitalism instead...
yup...

the original...Warner Brothers Big Screen Kung Fu King...Bruce Lee...

Mr. Han man...the guy with the iron hand...remember the brother getting his ass whipped with the Han's hand?

he owned an island...

さぃ…'s the one who brought up han chinese...
Pr0digalS0n seems to know about the han chinese...and more...

I just know...they have slanted eyes like me, and use long blunt plastic chopsticks...

but eskimos?...haven't a clue...the inuit...check the spelling...

100 yrs...let's see who looks like who...
Who out there is smart enough to elaborate to all us dum dums what a pure human culture is equal to?
I dunno...the Chinese?

maybe the Egyptians?

or do they consider themselves Arab?
Maybe Newfies are the purest.. but I digress. Isn't inbreeding a requirement of genetic purity?
who cares about toxins and chemicals if N.Korea, India, Pakistan, Iran, Russia, Cuba, and whoever starts nuking...

we'll be one race...the nukinese...
We'd have dishes like mutated deep fried shrimp seasoned with nuclear rated hot sauce and special fallout herbs and spices. Visit your nearest Nukinese restaurant today!
boy are we warped...

Scotty...make it so...

actually it's supposed to be Jordy...but Scotty is more famous...
In that case I'll have di-lithium crystals with my shrimp and borg'd'ouvres afterwards.
Mutants... ha!

The sad thing is that you don't have to be mutant to get mistreated in the US or Canada, or to have somebody assume you're a foreigner. All you have to be is somebody who looks Asian, Latino, Black, or Native American.
Pr0digalS0n> How true it is. That's changing a little at a time, but there will always be a reservoir group out there that is blissfully ignorant of cultural diversity and even frightened of the unfamiliar. I wonder if more accurate or politically correct labels for ourselves would help to remedy that situation?

Ha ha, and thanks for sort of getting us back on track to the original issue. (^-^)
What is wrong about assuming someone is a foreigner? If I saw an Asian person somewhere I would assume he is my countryman. Or on the other hand, if I saw a white person in China I would obviously think he is a foreigner. I was staying in America and some people always asked me if I am registered to vote. I found it extremely annoying.
My good sir ZhengYu, I believe you've partially answered your own question..
Guchi

maybe you are becoming cryptic...

ooooooooooo
Well, I guess we can all be like アラン sometimes.
(;◔ิд◔ิ) I like being occasionally cryptic. Does that make me mysterious?^^

ZhengYu, I don't know what else to say.. unless you want me to go into painful detail of what I read in your post.. I'll do that in a personal message if you prefer. Cheers.
What is wrong about assuming someone is a foreigner?

Especially when you live in Japan, European people are always assumed to be foreigners. Sometimes if you talk to a Japanese in Japanese, he might think he was talked to in English and become nervous... That's because Japanese look so similar and European look is very different from that. I guess that happens in most Asian countries... That is just recognizing the difference, and not discriminating or something.
I simply dont understand what is wrong about mistaken for a foreigner in America. If I see an asian person outside asia, of course I will think he is from asia. Does it matter where you are born or what citizenship you have? If you are Chinese, you are Chinese. No matter if you are born in China, Africa or America. If an american was born in Japan, he is not a Japanese right?
ZhengYu>
Maybe you don't understand what's wrong with being mistaken as a foreigner in America because YOU ARE A FOREIGNER in America. I just thought I'd point out what's obvious... no offense intended.

For people who identify themselves as Asian American, being constantly assumed to be a foreigner is troubling because there's often very ignorant attitudes behind the assumptions:

1) If you're Asian, you're not a "real American".
2) If you're not a "real American", you don't belong in this country.
3) If you don't belong in this country, then you have no right to be in it.

People of Asian ancestry in Canada face similar attitudes as well.
ZhengYu> This pertains to the question, "What's wrong with assuming someone is a foreigner?" You did say that you found it not just simply annoying but "extremely" annoying that people made assumptions about you. I guess while I can't see anything directly wrong with being assumed a foreigner, it could be pretty painful dealing with all the other baggage of assumptions that it comes saddled with. This is what I consider "bad" about assuming someone is a foreigner.

However much a Chinese person may want to claim an American born Chinese descent American as one of his own, that decision is completely up to the sentiment of that individual, and if they wish to be seen as an American (and it is their every right to feel so), then it could be a big problem if everyone automatically assumed he was always this "foreigner". The line is perhaps blurred at the first generation level, but the national identity of an individual is usually strenthened over successive generations in a country, and that identity is very much with the country of birth.

A person of Japanese or Chinese background who is born in America or Canada, according to myself and many of my own friends, could very easily consider themselves Canadian or American. Would you agree? I consider myself both Japanese and Canadian but more Canadian than Japanese when you weigh culture and way I think with greater import than genetic identity.

Though I doubt that there is any malicious intent behind the scrutiny, I get the, "look at the foreigner" stare quite often in Southern Alberta. It is not something I particularly relish.
Pr0digalS0n> Hey! You stole my idea! (´・ω・`) I guess that's what I get for being a slow typer.. he he
missed being 100th comment...waited too long...

well...101 is good...you know there was

Brew 101 in LA looooong ago...

of course, it's shut down...wonder if the plant is still there...

didn't even read any of the comments...felt like writing to myself...
I didn't even realize i was the 100th comment. More beer for everyone! Well, to the people I might eventually meet off this anyway.. cheers again, salude, salut, chin-chin, kanpai, and banzai.
Guchi>heh, well... great minds think alike!

I understand your feelings about being Japanese and Canadian, because for me, being a 4th generation Chinese American, it's the same in some ways. I'm proud of my Chinese heritage, and while I consider myself both Chinese and American, many of my beliefs, ideas, and perspectives about the world are definitely more American than Chinese.
Pr0digalS0n> It's always good to know you can have brothers other than just by blood. Cheers man.
I have other Japanese and Korean friends who like me were born in Germany. But nobody of us thinks that we are German just because we were born there. Citizenship laws differ from country to country. In some countries you automatically become a citizen when you are born there but I think in most countries you are more likely to inherit your parents' citizenship. We were all born and raised as foreigners in Germany and never had any problems with that. What do you expect? The Germans have a completely different culture and history from us. We can't identify ourselves with that.
I'm not talking about simply being born somewhere, but also being raised there. I can't speak for you Sergio, but you can't tell me that the environment I was raised in didn't affect me culturally. You seem to be telling me that as a Canadian that I have a completely different culture and history from all other Canadians.

Being able to identify with another culture is simply a matter of time and exposure. I'm not saying we'll ever feel like we fit in perfectly, but the world would be a more boring place if we did, and despite the out of placeness I may feel sometimes, I'm glad that I'm unique in many ways.

Look at the make-up of the Canadian population. Find me two people who aren't in the same family and I'll show you two people with completely different backgrounds and history. Sure, not every country in the world is like that but everyone is affected by the country of their birth. Are you going to say that nothing you experienced while you were in Germany (assuming you were there for a few years) affected the way you think or act? Did it not make you a different person from your Japanese counterparts who have yet to step off the Japanese islands?
Of course I think and behave differently from other Japanese. When I was in high school, I had more Korean friends and many people say that I think and also act more like a Korean. But I can't change the fact that I am a Japanese. I doubt that many Germans refer to the many Turkish, Moroccan and other people born and raised in Germany as Germans. Canada is a completely different case. Unlike Germany, which has been pretty much homogeneous throughout history, You have the English, the French, the First Nations and bunch of other people living together. Each group has a history on its own and I guess thats what makes up Canadian history as a whole. But what can you do? Both Canada and the United States were founded by White people and the mainstream culture is still White. Asians are still a small and also a silent minority and I can't blame the Whites for being unable to accept Asians as a part of their country yet. I believe it is a matter of time.
Ok, there's one thing that gets beaten into these lines of conversations over and over. Generalization. That's like the mother of all misunderstandings. You just can't blanketly state that all "whites" don't accept asians as part of their country. That's a pretty inflammatory thing to say about anyone. Just like you can't say that all Japanese, Koreans, Chinese, or asian-descent people think the same way.

I'm not going to go and say you aren't Japanese. That would just be stupid. If we're going to be honest and accurate, I'd say your own identification of yourself is the closest definition of what you are culturally. Perhaps I know your feelings of being out of place, or simply being displaced because of frequent movement to different countries. It's pretty understandable. In that sense, the culture of your parents is the only strong cultural link that has remained with you throughout the years, and that's why you identify yourself, (sometimes almost vehemently) as a Japanese.

If you ever find a country to settle down in, just watch and listen to your children. They will have claims to two cultures, and despite any effort on your part (short of taking them back to Japan), they will see themselves as children of their country of birth and upbringing (meaning if it's not Japan).

Take note that I mention Canada is different from Germany or other countries. But then, all countries are to a degree, different from each other.

I'm sorry I haven't taken the time to thoroughly read your profile. (My Japanese reading ability is pretty sucky) I have a few honest to goodness questions I'd like to ask. This is just so I can see where you come from in your posts a little better.

What countries have you been raised in? Do you feel any attachment whatsoever to those countries? I'm sure in a lot of ways you feel blessed with all the exposure to different cultures, but do you resent having been brought up in multiple countries at all?
Sergio> I forgot to add that I very much agree with your sentiment that acceptance of a wide variety of "ethnicities" is simply a matter of time. It's the salve of all misunderstanding.
Good thoughts Sergio and Guchi.

I just wanted to also echo that the US and Canada are very different than countries like Germany, the UK, China, or Japan. Those countries have long histories that have created a group of people who share a common culture, common language, and common ethnicity for the most part. Their histories straight back hundreds of years.

In contrast, the US and Canada are still very young countries. Even the US, which celebrates its "birthday" in 1776, is a very young country - only about 230 years old. Chinese and Japanese immigration to the US began in the mid to late 1800s, which means that for more than half of the country's history, Asian people have been involved in the forming of the country. Yonsei Japanese Americans or 4th generation Chinese Americans like myself are the descendants of people who built towns and railroads, planted crops and improved agriculture, fought and died in wars, etc.

Who says that just because you're Japanese or Chinese or any other Asian ethnicity, that you're any less American or Canadian? Our people helped to make the US and Canada what it is today, and I don't think anybody (especially white people) has the right to say that "we don't belong". That's BS. Our people have just as much right to "belong" as they do.

Whether or not non-Asians accept Asians as a part of the population of the US and Canada wouldn't be an issue if they actually understood the true history of North America... but given that the Asian American population has the highest growth rate behind the Hispanic population, it's only a matter of time before they will have to accept that Asian people are here to stay and that we have a say in how we choose to define what an "American" or "Canadian" is.
This is pretty cathartic stuff. I hardly ever have anyone to talk to about these issues. Thanks everyone.

Pr0digalS0n> You always give a lot of relevant input, thanks again.

ログインすると、残り77件のコメントが見れるよ

mixiユーザー
ログインしてコメントしよう!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆ 更新情報

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆のメンバーはこんなコミュニティにも参加しています

星印の数は、共通して参加しているメンバーが多いほど増えます。