So I, a non-gamer, went to the Tokyo Game Show this past weekend with some gamer friends; I was far more intrigued by the myriad of different cosplay characters than the latest offerings by the game developers. In the midst of my marvel, I started wondering: Why is cosplay such a "Japanese" phenomenon? Sure, people in France and other countries do it as well, but why do you think this sort of thing originated in Japan?
1. A form of escapism to get out of the real world.
2. We happened to have a manga/video game oriented culture in stead of Star Wars.
3. We don't have a chance to dress up as a different person like Halloween otherwise.
I'm not really sure what you mean by it being a Japanese phenomenon. The phenomenon part would be people that dress like that regularly, not people doing it at a convention. People dress up as superheroes at American comic book conventions, even before anime/manga got 'popular' here. THe only thing that makes it a "Japanese" phenomenon would be because anime/manga are Japanese products, but in the end it's still people dressing up as fictional characters, which is in no way, shape or form a phenomenon, nor is it in any way shape or form limited to Japan.
Certainly the US had Trekkie conventions fairly early on but I'd be curious to know where/when the cosplay thing really took off. I'd guess it probably started in the US scifi scene, got picked up in Japan, then bounced back to the US when the otaku boom hit.
I think the "act" in itself is fairly standard around the world. Carnival etc, who didnt dress up as a pirate or cowboy as a kid.
The thing is that the japanese seemingly do it all year around and to a later age though. Not sure how that can be explained but #1 makes a good point.
japanese ppl are the only ones that dont really give a shit about what other ppl think of them, cuz the general population is so tolerant of weird fetishes.
#4
> I'd be curious to know where/when the cosplay thing really took off.
Umm... does the word "masquerade" ring a bell? Obviously the whole concept of dressing as someone/something else began at the dawn of times, and was developed with a very pragmatic goal in mind - it was essentially a shamanistic ritual. Dressing up for entertainment is of course a latter invention; still, it dates some thousands of years back.
#11
> japanese ppl are the only ones that dont really give a shit about what other ppl think of them, cuz the general population is so tolerant of weird fetishes.
Eh? AFAIK, Japanese people are *extremely* conscious of what they think others think of them. That's why they have to mass up at various -cons; if you're cosplaying alone, you look like a fool, but if you're a part of a huge crowd - you're cool and trendy.
Why no, I've never heard of a cosplay masquerade before in my life. Thank you for educating me, smartass, but your answer really has no bearing to my question: where (arguably North America, most likely) and when (60s with Trekkies? 70s and 80s with the birth of major scifi conventions?)
And I just saw some dude walking around dressed like a giant cat in Shinjuku today, so between that, the random goth-lolis I run into on the train, and the test pattern hair colors that one can see just about anywhere in Tokyo I don't think Japanese are that self-conscious anymore.
#14
My, what a nice show of attitude, kiddo. Though I'd prefer to be called a wiseass, in the sense that even my ass is so wise that its wisdom is beyond your understanding. Well, since you seem to have a problem with English language, I asked my ass to explain it to you in a few more words...
Cosplay is an acronym for COStume rolePLAY, an activity when one puts on a costume to represent a specific character or idea. While being typically associated with anime, cosplay is not limited to it.
Masquerade is an event where participants wear costumes and masks, which, again, represent characters or ideas. Going back to my earlier post, tribal hunters, wearing costumes and masks of animals during a "magic" ritual for successful hunt are performing exactly the same activity, though for different purpose.
The only difference between these is that cosplay is not limited to specific events anymore. In other words, there's no "cosplay masquerade" - because masquerade IS cosplay. And no one will tell you the exact date of the first cosplay ever, because it does date back to the stone age.
So, as you might see, your problem (besides the attitude) is that you have restricted your personal interpretation of the term "cosplay" to people wearing costumes of anime or movie characters only. If going by your *extremely* limited definition, then the first cosplay event most likely was at the first Science Fiction Convention in New York, in 1939.
And i'm sure knowing all of that must have made you a hit with the anthropology club at your community college but that goes far and beyond the scope of the discussion.
Quoting Wiki,
"The term cosplay represents a contraction of the English words costume play. The term was coined by Nov Takahashi of the Japanese studio Studio Hard while attending the 1984 Los Angeles Science Fiction Worldcon. He was impressed by the hall and the costumed fans and reported on both in Japanese science fiction magazines. The coinage reflects a common Japanese method of abbreviation in which the first two moras of a pair of words are used to form an independent compound. Costume becomes kosu (コス), and play becomes pure (プレ)."
So the word itself has only been around for 25 years, which means nothing because again it's probably gone on for a bit of time. Can you cite anything involving people in costumes in 1939? It's a reasonable theory but I've never read anything along those lines; nor can I imagine anything like it because in my fantasies any scifi event that took place between 1950 has everyone dressed up in steampunk (which would be infinitely cooler than anything else that would have been cosplayed in the first place).
In any case the modern (i.e. last 5-10 years) version of cosplay is pretty much all about being an attention whore and/or proving that you have more free time to come up with elaborately intricate costumes than the other guys, and that's something we can all probably agree on.
> Can you cite anything involving people in costumes in 1939?
http://fanac.org/worldcon/NYcon/w39-p00.html has a photo of Forrest Ackerman in "futuristic" costume.
The site also has a few photos of "costume parties", as they were called back then, from the following WorldCons as well.
Not very widespread, of course, for several reasons. First, remember the political situation - civil war in Spain, Germany consuming several countries and preparing to start WWII, Japan preparing for the same thing in Asia... the faraway America is the only place something like NYcon could happen.
Second, it was only the beginning of the modern cosplay. Moral norms were pretty strict back then, and peer pressure was high; only the most daring of geeks would do that.
I meant within the context of the convention. Was there just one guy in "futuristic" dress, or several? I'm sure there's a group photo out there...
Does make me wish that modern fans could be a bit more refined. The joys of wandering the exhibition halls to see torn and stained D&D shirts left and right...
According to some attendees, there was definitely more than one person in a costume. I haven't seen any other photos myself to prove that, though. All those freaks must've been considered 'unimportant' by the photographer(s).
There's a group pic for 1946 WorldCon, though: http://www.fanac.org/worldcon/Pacificon/w46m010.html
Maybe I'm a little too old to go to those things and not
be looked at like a pervert but I did go to Super Nova in
Sydney for the past couple of years. There was a female
Storm Trooper (I mean the costume had breasts, hips
and high heel boots), but when the helmet came off, it was
a guy.
Even amongst the strangeness.....I thought that was quite
odd.