ログインしてさらにmixiを楽しもう

コメントを投稿して情報交換!
更新通知を受け取って、最新情報をゲット!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆コミュのJapanese only Party?

  • mixiチェック
  • このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加

Every now and then I hear from my Japanese friends about a party only for Japanese. A Japanese only party to me is wrong on so many different levels. I can tell you that if I was living in Japan I would not want to go to an American only party. What’s the point of excluding everyone else?

Can somebody out there please enlighten me on this subject?

Here is another thing to think about. Why is it that Japanese/Korean people study abroad to learn a language but only hang out with other Japanese/Korean people? Then they complain about not being able to speak or understand the culture.

コメント(48)

I've been an exchange student and the whole idea of it is to mingle with the culture you've exchanged in to.

What's the point in going to another country to only hang out with people from your own country? You could have saved yourself the airfares!
So if a Japanese-only party is objectionable, would a party that's limited to, say, graduates of a certain school be objectionable too?
Oh wait, is this just a bunch of friends hanging out, or is this some sort of Japanese community event? If it's the former, then yeah, I can see how that would be grating.
And how do we know that they don't mingle with the people here? We're only hearing this from one side. None of us know how much the Japanese people in the town mingle with the other students. It could be that they mingle a lot, and this is time they're just using for themselves. If that is the case, then they, at the very least, do deserve to have the chance to deal with their own, because I'm sure culture shock is a bitch. Seeing people around will make the transition a little bit easier. Being jealous and feeling left out because the Japanese Exchange students aren't paying you enough attention all the time is unfair to them.

However, if it is the opposite, and they never mingle, then it does defeat the purpose of them being over here. However, I'm believing that it is the former, and not the latter.
I never said that was the case, but given that you asked gattsu (and i merely responded to give an extra opinion) i assumed that you were referring to what was said in that comment. Which was the lack of mingling.
It depends. I've seen people whining about their "poor" English and how hard it is to get along with foreigners while they're constantly hanging with their own culture. Those, I don't get. Unless they don't try, it's pointless. On the other hand, there are people who don't care whether sticking together is a problem. Say, a person who major in mathematics don't consider communication as a big deal, they might think "hanging together"=not a problem with their carrier/academic goals.
So, there's a big difference, those who whine and those who don't.
Of course it could just be that the parties aren't Japanese-only; they just don't like you. ボケーっとした顔
ahh there were a few parties like that in Australia too, Japanese people only.

Makes you wonder


but why would you want to go to a party where you're not welcome anyway?ウインク
I see absolutely no problem with Japanese having a party where only Japanese are invited.

Sometimes I feel as if folks that have long-standing relationships with Japanese people can be naive when it comes to situations like this. The fact is there are cultural differences that take more effort to overcome than it is worth at a social gathering. Also let's not forget the language barrier that will exist 99% (disclaimer: percentage used to make a point) of the time.

Granted there are some non-Japanese who believe, and may well be, absolutely familiar with the cultural differences and might even be more comfortable speaking Japanese than some Japanese. These people are rare cases and Japanese people know this. When you attend a party, or better yet when you attend a party of your peers, you would most likely want to feel as at ease as possible would you not? I feel that in a social gathering of foreign exchange students that the goal of the gathering is to relax and let the natural "flow" of the party take the reigns. It is hard to "flow" if you have to stop every 10 minutes to explain the meaning of a Japanese word in <country> language or explain why you are doing something a specific way.

Not to mention that some of the Japanese at a party might want to talk *junk* about the <country> they are in and/or its inhabitants and doing so in front of the <country>'s inhabitants may prove difficult.

Also I would like to state that it would be best not to forget about some stereotypes that still exist to this day in Japan, which includes Japanese studying abroad, about foreigners and other countries. However that topic is best left to an entirely different community and discussion thread.
Some thoughts.

First. It is natural that people of their own "kind" will want to hang out together now and then. Living abroad for a long period can be intense. Learning the language, dealing with culture differences and just being away from all things familiar can be hard. So makes sense to me that people will gravitate to their own familiar groups as a coping method.

Second. Japanese only party in the US makes sense. As long as it isn't the only thing they do. I haven't seen any "gaijin" only parties here, but like others have said, people are selective about who they invite.

Maybe your solution is to have Japanese language parties yourself and invite a wide range of people.
So some people want to hang out with just their own nationality. Probably they want to relax and have fun and not have to keep explaining everything to a foreigner not fluent in the culture, let alone the language.

And maybe they are plotting the overthrow of the government. But seriously, I've seen gatherings of ethnocentric groups of all nationalities. It's the same reason why gays, lesbians, boy scouts, deaf, professionals and educators hang out with their kind. A common understanding where there is more being said by what is not said or how it's said or vague references to common knowledge that is only known to members of that group.

So don't get all worked up. Just chill and be cool and you'll get invited to the next party.
>Then they complain about not being able to speak or understand the culture.

I know a lot of sensitive foreigners in Japan with the same attitude.
It is almost like their every second breath is spent on bitching about the country.

e.g. why didn't they serve me chopsticks? Is it because I am gaijin????

whatever.... eat your whale and horse meat.LOL
Wait a minute... this mixi community is called "☆ENGLISH ONLY☆". What's up with that? Why do foreigners always exclude Japanese?

So wrong.
fenomas,

LOL! It's a wonder nobody has noticed that until now.
After talking to some of my Japanese male friends attending this party, they kind of indicated thatits more about them meeting japanese girls without the interruption of foreign males.

I do know a lot of Japanese people who would not even consider going to a Japanese only party. They figure that they are here to learn to speak english and rather not get involved the Japanese community which has the tendancy to "talk" about people.

I hear what Amber and everyone is saying about there need to "take a break" from english but I do not think that is the case.

> Wait a minute... this mixi community is called "☆ENGLISH ONLY☆". What's
> up with that? Why do foreigners always exclude Japanese?
> So wrong.
This community would be so bland without fenomas' wit. 指でOK
It happens, even in the US with other minorities besides Japanese. Even I throw "asian" parties because honestly no one else but us would understand what we are saying and doing. If someone was there from outside the group, i'd feel like I'd have to accommodate for them which makes the whole thing feel uneasy. However it doesn't mean I'll throw parties for everyone else.
Forgot to add, it was like that with my Japaneses students when I was an adviser. They had parties I wasn't invited to. But when I was, I just felt plain out of place. Felt like they were trying to accommodate for me which was extremely uncomfortable. In turn it was the same for them when I took them out to parties with my friends.
I agree with Mozzie.

Unless you are the type that likes to actively pursue Japanese women, you should probably do that on your own time. I wouldn't want to hang around people like that anyway. And then they seem to me like they're the type of men that either get offended when someone who is foreign gets more attention than they do in the department of women. I wouldn't even want to hang around people like that.

As long as they invite you to things, then that's fine, and you shouldn't flip out. But if they don't, you can find your own friends who won't give you the third degree. It doesn't sound to me that they want you to feel out of place - I think that they're intentionally leaving you out, be that because they may not like you as much as you like them/you may think that the like you, you could be unwanted competition, or they just may be the type of men who don't agree with Japanese women dating a non-Japanese male. (Which would be unfair if they were - and they're being douchebags, and really aren't worth your time)

Don't flip out over that. You can't get invited to everyone's party, and you can't be invited to every party being held by your friends. You keep on being a good person and keep on being friendly. I can totally sympathize because I got the 3rd degree by pretty much all groups of people, Asian, White, Latino and even my own people, and for a moment there, I wondered if there was a problem with me - until my mom straightened me out because she was sick of me calling. She gave me the whole thing that I'm giving you, and she also told me quite simply - "STOP BEFRIENDING ASSHOLES."

Best advice she ever gave me.
My humble, uninformed opinion:

I see no problem with a "Japanese-only" party. Maybe if it was a "No Americans Allowed" party there would be cause for concern.

They aren't trying to exclude a certain group, they just want to spend some time with the people they are most comfortable with. Is that unusual?

Of course it's a shame for the non-Japanese person, but just try not to take it too personally.
Advice from my roommate -

"You're being cockblocked. Cut them off."
Amber

I am not so much worried about this as I was in the past. You and your roommate have it right on, I am being cockblocked.

I just dont understand why they had to make a point to say it was a japanese only party. I wasnt going to invite myself or anything.
Yeah. That's why they keep telling you that it's a Japanese-only party. They are really hellbent on cockblocking you. Crap like that can work for the best, though, because when you piss a woman off, they'll likely talk shit about you to their friends, and the whole group of guys that tried to hook up with them can be guilty by association.

I'm not saying to be wolfish about it, but what I will tell you is that it makes things better for you because you won't have to be associated with people like that.
Those people are probably playing games like"King"that would just be hella uncomfortable with someone that they don't know really really well.

Anyways, the best way to parry their block is to hook up with a hot Japanese girl. It'll make their blood boil.

Or better yet, find a better group of Japanese people to hang out with, and try not to speak/learn Japanese the whole time.

I'm sure you don't need advice from me, so good luck on finding new, cool Japanese friends.
In all countries someone will exclude someone else. I think that most Japanese people are very kind and I dont think that Japanese people want to exclude non japanese, maybe it was just people having the activities.
Japan is a very excluding country. I wouldn't feel bad if I were you...but look at it this way:

If you're born in Japan to non-Japanese parents you are not "Japanese".

If you hold a Japanese passport, but were born to Japanese parents OUTSIDE of Japan, you are not "Japanese".

If you study abroad for a year or more, you are a "returnee" and therefore are no longer 100% "Japanese".

Of course being Japanese by law and nature are two different things in Japan.

This mentality has created many selfish groups of study-abroad Japanese, but there are always those Japanese people who do not feel the need to exclude others in order to feel comfortable.

I understand it is their "right" to do as they please, but it is also your right to befriend whomever you want, so go away from those kinda stuck-up snobs and find some true friends who will never say you aren't like them enough.

In my University, two of my best friends were Japanese and NEVER would think about attending a party without me being there (and one of them is "culturally" the most Japanese person I've met).
"After talking to some of my Japanese male friends attending this party, they kind of indicated thatits more about them meeting japanese girls without the interruption of foreign males. "

This is almost always 100% the reason for such actions. But I have seen this many times before in Shibuya, Nagoya, Osaka, etc.. From hostess bars to strip clubs and worse. Get rid of the competition. Makes sense to me. Get over it. Those parties attract like minded people ( ladies and men) that attend because they don`t want to interact with foreigners. So fuck em. There was a time when I would have really gotten pissed off about this type of thing, but it is just not worth it. Believe me, if you are not welcome, you don`t want to be there.
リラックミル,

>> If you study abroad for a year or more, you are a "returnee" and therefore
>> are no longer 100% "Japanese".

The interesting thing is, it is typically those who have been abroad for a year or two that try to distance themselves from the "ordinary" Japanese. They feel that being able to (somewhat) speak English and behaving (somewhat) like Westerners are cool. As far as I can tell, the longer a Japanese stays abroad, the more he/she tries to assimilate himself/herself into the Japanese society once he/she is back in Japan. Not really a relevant discussion here, but I thought I'd mention that for you. :)
Dannydinkle>
that's common even in Tokyo, an "half" kid with no father will be definitely discriminated, not only by his classmates but also by the teachers.
だいはどさん、

I totally agree with what you said, but at the same time, even if one didn't publicise their former past and it was found out, they'd still be considered a "returnee" IMO.

I've seen very small children who return from abroad (parents transferred companies) who are also considered "returnees", even though they studied in Japanese schools setup for 会社 kids and are too young to have a complex about living abroad.
about the half child business:
I think "half" kids being discriminated against or treated differently is just normal. There is no where you can go to escape this. It's something you have to get used to.
Whichever "home country" you will go to there will always be someone who will say that you are not of that nationality.
I knew some Japanese and Koreans and other nationalities in the US who sometimes had parties consisting of only people from their same countries, I think now and then it's okay, sometimes they wanna be able to have a familiar atmosphere and language together. If you do it all the time and don't socialize otherwise, then it's not good for your social life I think.

Sometimes I got invited to the Japanese or Korean parties because I was studying the languages and they thought it would be a good way for me to practice and just having me and maybe one or two other non-Japanese/non-Koreans would be okay and not really disturb the comfort zone. I think some people are worried about inviting too many people who aren't familiar with their culture and communication style and not being able to relax so much.

I see it like this...
I usually go out to Japanese clubs and bars, but every now and then, having some drinks at the gaijin bar can be kinda fun in a different way.  But spending every night at a gaijin bar can really hinder your social development in Japan.

ログインすると、残り15件のコメントが見れるよ

mixiユーザー
ログインしてコメントしよう!

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆ 更新情報

☆ENGLISH ONLY☆のメンバーはこんなコミュニティにも参加しています

星印の数は、共通して参加しているメンバーが多いほど増えます。