One of my friends wanted a job in Tokyo as a kids English teacher and he told me that all the kindagardens ask a degree for this position..I thought he is joking or asking special early childhood education degree..but it was true..they are just asking 4 years degree whatever it is!!
He is a native and still college student with working holiday and the positions which he showed me was saying "you will be teaching 2〜5years old kids".
Isn't it funny that the teacher of 2 to 5 years old kids should have a degree!?
why do they ask such degree as long as what he will be teaching probably animals names and some songs??
In japanese society, academic background occupies a big part.
Not only for foreigners but also japanese.
I dont think it is needed when they teach English.
But parents are happy with that teacher is educated well.
いそっち>>
I don't think that parents asks about the education's background.
I worked up to 4 years teaching English and ve just found few months ago that my Japanese assistant (who works with me 4 days a week for over than a year) didn't know my college major..how about about students and parents
I also hate the way of japanese society.
They really care about which uni we graduated.
Schools are kind of brand, I guess. So they tend to
employ people who are educated at very high valued schools.
They really need to change the point of getting person.
I mean not only school but more important thing is
personality. So I think it's totally fine of your friends to teach kids
because (s)he really wants to do.
Then if (s)he is really poor of it, they can just hire, I think.
As everyone mentioned, japanese society is different from other countries, which i really hate!!!
One of important things to get a job in japan is which university or college you are from, what qualification you have...your educational background occupies a big part. Actually this refers to japanese.
I also think it's stupid they asked him a degree...just should ask him to submit a criminal record or something and intervew and judge him if he is suitable for the job!
>> if somebody really wanna do something he will be
>> really talented and excel on it even if he is not
>> major of it.
I understand what you're saying, but in my opinion, that's way too idealistic. I don't think having a degree is everything, but it does show the potential employer that you have worked hard to achieve something. Like "..." says, it may just be a visa issue, too.
>> They really care about which uni we graduated.
This does not apply here, because any bachelor's degree is apparently good enough.
BTW, I personally believe teaching preschool kids English is a tough job. It's not something just any native speaker of English can do.
I've argued this issue with people here in the US too. I've always felt that foreign language should be taught in a fun and basic way for extremely young kids. Then as they get older, more expirienced teachers should step in.
I agree with the others that a college education just has a different meaning in Japanese culture. A huge percentage of Japanese go to college. It's maybe comparable to senior high school education in western countries.
>>momoさん
Everyone can see other's academic background.
But how can we see if a teacher is talented,
if he/she has a good personality,
if he/she is trustworthy?
Would you interview a teacher?
You might do that, but usually people don't.
So, people can't judge it unless we spend much time with him/her.
However, academic background is true.
And the point is that, in Japanese society in which
academic background occupies a big part,
which teacher would parents choose:
the teacher from Tokyo University or
the teacher who has not graduated from a university.
That's what I meant.
>>momoさん and あずぅさん
I really agree with だいはどさん.
To teach is professional job.
I study linguistics and know slightly about language aquisition and language leaning.
Usually, children aquire language through exposure.
It is only children who can aquire language in this way.
So, people of the age of more than 12 have to study and
learn to speak other languages than their native language.
Then, is it aquisition or learning?
I think neither, but it is rather learning than aquisition
because only 1 hour exposure a day is obviously too little.
Children should be taught English in an effective way.
For this reason, as だいはどさん mentioned,
to teach English to children is a tough job,
and needs professional knowledge.
いそっち >>
For this reason, as だいはどさん mentioned,
to teach English to children is a tough job,
and needs professional knowledge
- by this way, they have to ask for early childhood education degree not generic degree..
You went out of the topic subject man..
an electronic engeneer or computer programmar can teach kids in "professional knowledge" cuz they are graduated from 4 year college? while my friend in the 2d year of English literature college in UK can't? come on..
>> by this way, they have to ask for early childhood
>> education degree not generic degree..
Yes, it is true, although a "generic" bachelor's degree does show the potential. Or it may just be that there's not enough job candidates with the appropriate education degree or teaching certificate.
>> my friend in the 2d year of English literature
>> college in UK can't?
I don't think majoring in English Literature would help much when it comes to teaching English to young kids, either.
Now just curious, how does a college student from abroad legally get a job in Japan? Here in the U.S., foreign students can work up to 20 hours a week on campus, but they need a special permission , which is very rarely granted, to work off campus.
i think BA/BS degree is required to have working visa issued. (i used to be a recruiter at English school.)
I think that the requirements for the US working visa are much more strict. Let's say you are CPA, but the job you are having in the US has nothing to do with accounting, they dont let you in(as far as i know). You have to have both your major and your job matched in order to have your working visa issued.
I agree degree has nothing to do with personality. I have hired people with higher degrees like Ph.D in Education, but some were SO irresponsible, but some even w/o those degree were so nice and kids actually loved them. Degree is something that only objectively testifies that you have enough education, but can never testify if the person is nice.
I agree that collage graduates aren't necessarily better than non-collage grads. If I know the person is good as a person personally, I don't care much of his/her academic background. However, when it comes to business, school has to set some kind of qualification standard.
From parent's perspective, I won't send my 4-years-old to any English school, if the teacher is non-native speakers or who can't speak proper English, having tatoos/body piercing, who has drugs/alcohol problems, etc. Why should I expose my kid to "inappropriate" environment spending a lot of money!
I'm not saying all collage grads are appropriate.
As to academic career-based socisty, US is more stringent. To become a nursery/kindergarten teacher, most of the schools require "early choldhood education" or "child phychology" degrees these days. Most of ESL teachers who teach English to teenagers or above are usually required Master's degree or PhD. Sadly enough, Bachelor degree doesn't worth much....
well i guess it's important for the kindergarten to make sure that the kids parents know the person knows how to deal with kids as well as how to teach. u don't just get degree for being able to speak English but to teach in different situations...
>>Now just curious, how does a college student from abroad legally get a job in Japan? Here in the U.S., foreign students can work up to 20 hours a week on campus, but they need a special permission , which is very rarely granted, to work off campus.
the same in Japan..student work as part time worker as he/she will be holding working holiday visa usually.
Ange>>
Usually the company (agent) train the teacher how to deal and teach kids before starting his job actually.
#5>
Yes, mostly it is a VISA issue.
I know that here in Canada, no matter who you teach or where, we are required to have a 4 year degree to teach English in Japan. Doesn't matter if it is a teaching degree.
Yes, it can be out of the topic,
but we didn't go so far.
If you say we are out of the topic, so are others.
Visa doesn't matter either, does it?
Let me go back to the comment 3 by you.
Why did you mention your assistant?
He/she is not a parent, is he/she?
It seems to me that you just want to find fault with me.
I am sorry.
Then, let me ask you.
What do you think about my idea that
"In japanese society, academic background occupies a big part.
Not only for foreigners but also japanese."
I don't think it is especially bad, but it is because i don't have a degree!
Also, the fact that for all Japanese schools (i think) you must have a degree to teach English, even if your degree is not in teaching or english! So a friend of mine who has a degree in computers or something can teach, and i can't, even if i had teaching experience and a real passion for it!
it makes me sad! I didn't go to university because i had nothing i wanted to study really.. now i want to go and study japanese. But it frustrates me.. People who studied and got a degree which they don't use can do something which is a dream of mine :(
It's ok.. i can still teach private lesson if i go to Japan!
Knowing something is easy ...but beleive you me teaching is a different ball game all together..
and that too to a specified target audience like lil kids.
Kids teacher should be the best of the lot, as the teachers have lot of influence on the brain development of kids.
Momo, in my opinion you seem to think too simple, concerning kids education.
Infact I think knowledge of any subject you want to teach the kids isn't that much important as your experience in education.
Moreover, teaching kids isn't that easy as it sounds. Even if your friends speaks the best english in the world, it is no use if he doesn't know how to make kids remember what he told them.
Therefore I'm not surprised at all, I think the kindergarten's decision is alright. Either me wouldn't send my kids to educaters who have no experience about education at all. And i'm not japanese.
If you teach English as a job, teaching skill should be required. Just being native speaker doesn't equal having an ability to teach English. Especially for kids, you have to have knowledge how to treat them.
I heard that an English teacher has to have a special degree for it in the UK.
In my experience, I would surely say that English teachers in London(having degree) were much more competent than the ones in Tokyo(just being native speaker&no degree).
I don't dispute that teaching is difficult, but the point i take issue with is the requirement of ANY degree.
If japanese schools said "you need a degree in teaching to teach here" then i think this is ok, and fair enough.
But, they say "you need a degree". Any degree. If you have a degree in computer science, in film, in maths, ANYTHING.
People who have no interest in teaching at all can become English teachers in Japan, cos they have a degree in SOMETHING. But even if i study teaching at a college, and get a good qualification (this is enough, you don't need a degree to teach english in london), it doesn't count for anything in Japan.
Personally I think it's good that they want people with degrees. You wouldn't just want some random person with no education teaching your kids would you? At least if the person has a degree the employer knows they're at least a little smart, dedicated enough to stick with something for 4 years, and isn't some crazy who just decided they wanted to teach.
Siegrid13 >>ラフィ >>
guess again we have people jumping out of the topic here..
the issue is not what is the education for kids..the issue what the companies are requiring.
what I said previously (please read what I wrote). that the company should ask for early childhood or not ask any degree..cuz generally if you hold degree or not as long as you don't have childhood education background, you are the same to teach kids in this case.
and you said: " Either me wouldn't send my kids to educaters who have no experience about education at all. And i'm not japanese."
cool the computer engineers has experience about education and you will send your kids to learn from them..you are cool!!
by the way, I hold a degree in hotel management, but I am training teachers how to teach kids and dealing with them...and I work as ALT too and over that I design materials for teaching kids !! mmm, probably, I should quit my jobs tomorrow...hahahaha!!!
I apologize to the computer engineers about the reply above as doesn't mean that they are not good at teaching kids though..it's just an example same with any major like Hotel management (Mine).
>what I said previously (please read what I wrote). that the......
Then, why don't you READ WHAT I WROTE?
Besides, I think Pink Spiderさん explained
why general degrees are needed for native speakers
in a situation where they teach very easy words.
(This is what you asked at first,
as long as I understand from your statements.)