So it goes like this....I was trying to explain to my Japanese workmates about 'catching holy ghosts' - like people do in southern baptist churches. Most cultures have some form of this, but they couldn't tell me the Japanese version....they said there wasn't one.....is this true? (Going to a rave and taking E doesn't count, I'm talking about non drug assisted euphoria etc)
I think they really couldn't get the concept of 'catching a holy ghost' → In my personal, and very bad, opinion this would explain in part why Japanese music is so bad.....I dunno, set me straight here
yeah thanks for the insights as always (the deli at park hyatt was a winner by the way - actually found Isetan's meat dept. wasn't too bad either, they stocked spanish Jamon!)
Umm, Ryuichi Sakamoto is very big isn't he...I think his score for the movie 'Merry Christmas Mr.Tom' or whatever it was called introduced him to the western world - and let japanese TV endlessly call him "sekai no Ryuichi Sakamoto"
Blue Hearts are a karaoke staple in my office so I'm familiar with them, and who could forget 'tomodachi' by ketsumeishi...haven't heard 'Bonnie Pink' I'll check them out...
OK, your explanation of the religious underpinning of culture would certainly explain why Japanese (and asians in general?) don't catch holy ghosts - thanks.....and yet there are so many punk and rap groups in Japan...would it be safe then to extrapolate that they can't embody the full spirit of their genre since they may have a fundamental absence of soulful torment?...(← I didn't like that sentence, 'soulful' is a gay word...anyway)
Yeah I guess I shouldn't say Japanese music is bad, just seems like it's missing something - maybe because I'm a westerner I'm missing something - I guess so listening to your explanation anyway....my workmates say Japanese music is great too, but for every one example they can give me I can think of multiple western artists that do it better. It's not about "we're better than you ha ha ha" etc, I'm wondering why such a rich culture hasn't produced more, moving and original work....Japanese TV, commercials, print, video games, and graphic design in general are so advanced I often wonder why the music doesn't reflect that.....maybe the Japanese language just isn't that musical or something I don't know....
B.Spears is a travesty of natural justice, but musically western pop is not as bad as Japanese pop I'd say - although western pop has now arrived at the 'japanese' level where there is no pre-requisite for being able sing, even just a little, before you can get signed. That SMAP tv show where they do a live number at the end is probably, even though we're only 5 years in, the most ballsy work of pop art humour in the 21st century. Seriously though, after such a long career in music they can't even hold a note, hilarious. Abba are...well....I believe their music is a fixed staple of music school curriculums now - so there must have been some musical value in there...Spice Girls are from the UK so I'll take the bullet and say m(. .)m on behalf of my countrymen and women...
p/s I'd give anything to see that wig guy from 'toku da ne' catch a holy ghost...please send him one god....just once.....it'd only take a minute out of your day....and time is probably a non issue fro you anyway...so....well you get my drift etc....
I forgot about Itako.... Traditionally the women are blind and tend to be soothsayers of some sort. Freaky stuff. It isn't really religious and the whole rambling is not a spazz fest like the speaking in tongues you see in America or in most of Christiandom.
I did see one spazz in Harajuku, a woman dancer, when the roads used to be cordoned off on SUndays... but that might not count as she was spazzing to Bjork.
Its true there really wasn't a whole lot of soulful torment in traditional Japan, if you were to suffer, you did the honorable thing and cut your guts out. Interesting that suicide is honorable in Japan, while viewed as a sin in Christianity....
Recto> thanks for the info! I wasn't aware of the 'itako' phenomenon at all...I'd like to ask you which demonination of christian you are (if you wouldn't mind telling me) - I have met some Japanese christians, and I had the rare pleasure of going to Goto-retto some years back and most people there were christian - they still recited in latin! (and portuguese) - but it was kinda strange latin, not like the latin I learnt in school. The kyushu christians were basically catholic, but christians I've met in Tokyo tend to be protestant...
I'm catholic and 'catching holy ghosts' isn't really allowed - you'll get labelled as a "stigmati", we tend to just get told how evil we are and that we should get it together or we'll burn in hell etc - if suicide weren't a cardinal sin I think millions of catholics would've taken that option through the ages....
So the Japanese christians who do 'igen' are they protestant or is that not really a factor?
Also a totally non-related topic but, I don't really consider Buddhism or Shinto as 'religion' as we westerners know it, I think they are more 'lifestyles' 'ways of thinking' etc
the only reason u think western music is better is because u know it better. u recognise the artist and u ignore the chaff.
if u had brains or balls maybe u would know that there are so many punk bands in japan who r "soulful" enough to blow ur shitarse stereotypes out of the water.
but hey, i can't give u the experience over the internet, try going to see struggle for pride live, which ain't hard when they play four shows a week and the singer doesn't need a microphone cos he is violently and brutally "catching a holy ghost" right in front of ur lame motherfucking face.
i think buddhism and shinto are very religious, if you look at the people who really believe those and practice hard their precepts(am i using right word? hope everybody understand me..)
buddha's dharmas are not like everybody own published book of it or anything. but sometime his words sounds similer to the words in bible to me.
i don't really have any certain belief but listening to buddhist monk numerating "okyo" (ching?) are like catching-a-holy-ghost-thing to me. their voice and the beats of "mokugyo" block.
and,
this is my first time i leave a comment on some topic on this community.. hello and thank you for reading. *bow*
Personally, I feel that there's a lot of ... idunno how to describe it. I was raised Jewish though, so we don't exactly have that "catching a holy ghost" sort of craziness either.
But, the feeling and もののあわれ of the human condition I think is something that came across very strongly in classical Japanese vocal music and is an aesthetic element I really admire. As others have said it contrasts heavily in emphasis with Southern Christian "spirits", but the idea of もののあわれ in traditional Japanese arts I find to be a very important and powerful idea.
I also have to say that I love Japanese music although it took a bit of an adjustment period. I don't see it as a holy grail of perfect music, but I do think that it's on par (and in some ways surpasses) modern American music in terms of the creativity of the independent music scene and I would advise looking into independent music much more than looking at jpop. Don't get me wrong, there have been good bands in major labels but you'll get a lot more diversity and style if you check out some random live concerts in Tokyo and look at what the underground is doing.
Hi everyone. I wanna elaborate more on what Cohiba said.
According to my professors, Japanese music(hougaku) you're speaking of is not really Japanese music. It's western style music performed in japanese by japanese in japan. IN the 60s and 70s japanese artists who played rock/pop style music's records were labeled under YOUGAKU(westernmusic) whilst the rest under Hougaku..stuff like enka is old old western influenced yet in a japanese-esque mode (harmonic minor key)
Anyway,
Like Cohiba said...
Japan's wonderful world of music lies in it's traditional arts. Noh-gaku, Gagaku, Kabuki, Jiuta, Nagauta, Bugaku, Katarimono, Heike biwa etc etc etc...
Japanese traditonal music embraces nature and the earth. ie:Shakuhachi music is a lot of times is recreating the daily life of a crane. I just finished working on a song called Yachiyo shi-shi on the Koto. The melodies and countermelodies in the vocal line over the koto accompaniment have this strange way of chasing each other...it's almost magical. It's hard to listen to when you're so adjusted to western music, but if you know what the music is about...it makes a world of a difference.
Go watch Noh theater. If you do your homework before you go and can get a grasp on what's going on, you'll be mesmorized by the slow precise movements and you'll see that there is certainly a soul in Japan.
Japanese music/arts is not gaudy like the music of the west. When you believe that you come from the earth and when you die, you go back into the earth...the music/arts stay simple, humble and near the earth.
Western music in contrast has it's roots in the church. Thus, the music is trying to take you to a higher place..to a higher ground. Listen to music from every period, baroque's Bach, Classical's Mozart, Romantic's Tchaikovsky, Early Modern Stravinsky...
It's all trying to bring the listener to a euphoric place.
Then enter american music which is almost 100% rooted in african americans. Blues + Gospel + the classical techniques of the Mixed/multiracial cajun ragtime musicians brought about Jazz.
Blues got watered down into rock and roll. THen all the white people went off and now u got money mixed up in the whole thing and you got shit like britney spears all over the place.
NOW
in the meantime, Japan opened up during the Meiji period and was heavily influenced by Austrian/German music. So classical music in Japan became a huge success, while at the same time traditional arts were going strong...it wasn't till post world war 2 that traditional japanese music started to fade away...
apparently the americans that came here to help re-establish government were in charge of filtering any kind of propaganda that would spark any kind of pride in the old "feudal" japan. So, many manuscripts of music and plays were burned or thrown away. Musical Japan was in a way forced to assimilate to american/western music methodologies and what not.
I'm not being as clear with facts as I should, but basically, try not to judge the current pop culture of Japan.
Money backs a lot of what you hear.
Just like the record industry in America...Image sells.
It's almost worse here, with companies like Johnny's controlling a large amount of the pop idols.
Look beyond what the radios and TVs feed you.
There are great artists here. They're just not fed to you.
oh yeah and about hip hop and what not...I heard a quote somewhere stating that "The african american man is the most copied/immitated man in today's pop culture"
so, when i see kids on the street in umeda wearing all blue and then another group wearing all red or yellow or some shit...then acting like they're in a gang...bangin shoulders and acting like street life is fuckin rough...i wanna go ask him...I bet your mommy made you your miso soup this morning...wanna roll?
>Bundle, you are correct and dead on about that. Japanese punk rock is excellent. I'm friends with the guys in PET and the girls in Rock and ROll Bacteria and got a chance to see Cobra and a bunch of other punk bands at an event that i worked staff at in Osaka.
Punk rock was born in an urban atmosphere from people not wanting to live crappy mundane lives and thrives in Japan. Punk's become teenager mall music in america...it's a shame.
probably bush's fault.
It's not about "we're better than you ha ha ha" etc, I'm wondering why such a rich culture hasn't produced more, moving and original work....Japanese TV, commercials, print, video games, and graphic design in general are so advanced I often wonder why the music doesn't reflect that
(I was talking about modern Japanese music...not classical Japanese music by the way)
--------------------
So Japanese punk is great? If you say so - but you only gave me one example...which was shit. Does anyone outside Japan know that band you mentioned? Does anyone outside Japan know 'The Clash', 'NOFX', and 'The Sex Pistols'? That's what I'm talking about you fuck, Japan has such a large music industry (2nd largest in the world) and no internationally famous artists, save R.Sakamoto....and don't start on language and marketing....
Onto live shows, 'catching a holy ghost' was a conversation about religious euphoria....if you want to start talking about performers catching holy ghosts go ahead but no-one else is talking about that because we can all read english you fucking wank rag.
It's funny how you think you're so above us, and you're the one who's been constantly posting comments on ENGLISH ONLY for two or so days - LIKE A SAD FUCKING TWAT...
Finally am I 'pseudo intellectual'? Ok whatever, tell you what - lets meet up for real, and I'll smash your fucking head in or bring a boyfriend and I'll fucking splash his brains all over the fucking pavement you piece of fucking shit....I think that would be the best way to settle this....with violence...because that's what I want to do to you, I'll save psuedo intellectualism for those who know where the word 'psuedo' comes from....
p/s the X-games was originally marketed by ESPN as 'a way of life' so fucking there - I know more than you ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha...this is the game we're playing isn't it cunt?
----------------------------------------
Dear everyone else,
Thanks for the comments. Yeah, the comparison I was trying to draw was particularly about 'pop' or mainstream music because that's the easiest way to compare I think. If we start talking about indies it's gets more difficult because I think that would generally be labelled as 'real' music regardless of the country, and also our musical preferences enter into the equation. Most of us don't like mainstream music so it's easier to comapre as we're more indifferent to it....
Jyasuran thanks for the explanation....I've never been to Noh, I doubt I could last a full performance as I've heard they go on for hours and hours, but it was interesting to read your comment. I guess it sounds like we may have an intrinsic 'filter' based around the western musical scale, that makes classical japanese music confusing at first....
And totally with you on Japanese rap kids, especially those who try to use rap slang. And yet don't know any real slang, or where it comes from. Like biscuits, onions, juks, baguettes, 7:30, etc. Much less that it's all regionalized...
Anyway, sounds like you all think Buddhism and Shinto should be considered religions. Thanks for that.
gee, what an angry, worked-up panty-twisted response...must have hit a nerve...
NOFX and the Sex Pistols? hahahha
now who's the sad twat?
if that's your definition of soulful music, then u r a sad cunt indeed.
those are pop bands, for fuck's sake. next thing u'll start comparing green day and morning musume and wondering out loud why white people seem just 'so much cooler' than the asians.
"hmmmm, why can't they get it right?" gee, buttfuck, maybe cos the japanese music industry isn't interested in catering to your sycophantic golden oldies cocksucking tastes? hmmm?
for someone who tries to talk about 'soulful' music and then judges that music on international profile or record sales is confused to say the least. still, when schmucks like you get riled up, they tend to trip over their own dipshit tongues while raving like a drunken english teacher.
so, u'd like to beat me up cos i called u out like the pussy u are? what a big, big, tough man.
hey, don't let the fact that i'm a pregnant girl stand in the way of your beating on females who don't agree with your sceptic semi-racist diatribes...
cos you're a cool white guy who can 'read' english.
yes, you're a real winner and a charisma man all the way.
teenager mall music in America....and what the hell is punk in Japan?? For that matter, what the hell are the Japanese superdoopermiddleclasstoosecureforwords youth doing attempting punk, Hip Hop or any other form of musical or artistic expression that requires HARDSHIP and a PROBLEM to create??? Oh yeah its rough, there parents didnt get them the ketai they asked for....bummer, its only a mova....
I know punk rockers in America, for better or worse who would break bones after reading ( if they could read it) that comment written above.
Allow me to assist you. If you are doubting Americas punk rock legitimacy, by all means venture to Huntington beach California (this is one of many locals by the way) cruz around for a couple days, meet a couple people who can help you meet a couple people and go to a decent show. It will be punk rock, I assure you.
ANGST
UNNECCESARY VIOLENCE
ANARCHY EMBRACED AND PERSONIFIED
Good luck making it out in one piece.
I would also wager to say that someone who has there noes in the books over in Japan studying classical japanese music blah blah blah doesnt know a fucking thing about punk rock. hey I could be wrong, sure you might be harder than a coffin nail and munching a on a dead baby skull (not that I know punkers who do this mind you) but somehow I doubt it.
In closing this particular rant I would like to say
great words there, yes it's true caustic insults like that really hit a nerve with me.....
fuck all your bullshit attempts to make an argument, what we're gonna talk about here is this ;
YOU'RE JUST GONNA TALK THE TALK AND NOT WALK THE WALK? So who's the fuckin' pussy cuntface? What kind of fucking punk are you?
You claim to be into grime - you fucking don't know shit about grime or where it comes from, so unless you grew up on a council estate (I did) you should fucking shut it - because we show and prove, that's the culture twat...you must be one of them trendy 'wanna be' cunts, getting up on the rebel element in music but too pussy to live it...here's the news you fucking pregnant shit - REAL HEADS FUCKING BACK THEIR WORDS UP, so.....stop insulting every post on this site, unless you're prepared to get your shit pushed in....come on I dare you, instead of your safe little live show where you jump around and push each other thinking you are dangerous come out on the street and meet me and I'll break your shit up, I don't give a fuck what sex you are or if you're pregnant or whatever....REAL HEADS BACK THEIR WORDS UP, I can
how wild and real u must be, i bet u even have a hard on RIGHT NOW! the way u type is just so.....street.
after all ur fake wanna-be skater posturing, now u claim to be one of the originators of grime cos ur parents were too fucking poor to buy condoms?
of course it's cute the way u paint yourself as an intelligent, yet violent and aggressive homosexual with no morals or qualms, just like a real gangsta.
c'mon, u r just some uptight english-teacher fag, pretending to be tough on the internet. how passe.
Archangel
=========
why do u think all ur boys at home are so real and all the japanese punks are spoiled middle-class brats?
that's just fucking stupid.
there are plenty of middle-class wanna-be punks in america and plenty of hard-life working class punks in japan with no futures.
u just sound out of touch.
let's be honest here. u white guys will never believe anything that asians do in music could ever be as real as urselves cos u fetishisize urselves in the extreme.
it's a typical white boy fantasy that somehow ur lives are emotional and real, which so totally sounds like NIN school-boy angst. it's whiny, and pathetic.
the Sex Pistols were good middle-class art school boys.
a lot of ur hip-hop gangstas on mtv are totally from middle-class homes.
do u think there r no people in japan leading hard desolate lives?
do u think there r no junkies or crime?
do u think japanese punks r welcomed by mainstream society or could ever get a 'real' job?
ur beliefs are sooo fucking two-dimensional and sub-racist and i thank god that the actual ppl that play in punk bands who tour japan have nothing but respect for the local scene.
u two white tourist party boys are 100% fake.
talk about being real? i'm the realest thing u'll never meet.
goodnite assholes, why don't u go strut ur stuff down at gaspanic?
hey, what's up with those guys saying you can't listen to music unless your are poor?
wtf?
so only black ppl can listen to hip-hop? so only english ppl can enjoy uk garage?
you guys sound like the worst elitist jazz snobs ever.
and what's with that guy saying japanese are too middle-class to be punk? what punk would ever say that?
and what are you guys doing that's so rebellious?
you're attacking bundle cos she likes music? man, that's just lame.
don't belittle people cos they are into music and they don't go around bombing police stations and stuff.
i bet none of you guys do that either.
what makes you so much better anyway?
do you have more of a right to buy cds than her cos she is japanese?
people like you think that japanese have to listen to enka cos they are not western.
well, rock and roll didn't start in england and there are plenty of hip-hop groups in france and even drum and bass guys in america. they all do it because they love the music and you don't need to be tough or get into fights just to like some kind of music.
you guys are sounding like beefed up macho rednecks more than anything else.
Wow! This community is rock N sock robot excellence.
Archangel-
I'm quite aware of the dudes down around hunington beach that would put a boot down my throat.
If you happened to look at my page and the picture of me playing bass, I'm playing with a punk band called the PUBES based in St.Louis. I was called in for some shows since their bass player was out...dead or something serioud/hardcore. I've played in punk bands and have an array of gutterpunk friends in Chicago and NYC.
...
I shouldn't have gone and slammed american punk rock for being so popularized. But the punk rock communities in america tend to be elitist....
You don't walk the walk, talk the talk and fit in the tribe then you get a brick in the mouth.
It wasn't like that when Patti Smith, The Damned, X, FEAR, Iggy Pop and the Germs were around.
Punk has been commercialized for the angst/uneasy "pay attention to me" youth of america.
In Japan...I think Yamambas and Ganguro are more or less today's version of the "daddy pay attention to me" epidemic.
I don't dislike punk rock considering all the recordings I have by so many wonderful punk rock artists...including TSOL...(saw you like em as well) Shiit I even went out and bought the operation IVY disc when I was in junior high school. I think even the honest to god punk rockers in america are rather dispappointed in their stylings/fashions being sold at Hot Topic and Whatever the name of the fat girl punk rock store is...hahahahaha.
ANyway, I'm not as hard as nails, but I'm also not some motherfucking book worm. I'm a real goddamn musician, with some real fucking worth. I'm here to study the music of Japan because to me, having your hand in every genre, every single possible genre in the world; can lead one to becoming an all around outstanding/ well rounded and well spoken musician. Look at David Bowie! He's had his hands in all sorts of genres.
I've just decided to utilize my language abilities to learn about a wonderful culture's traditional arts so I can better myself (and the narrow self obsessed oxidental world), does that make me a fuckin nerd?
I agree with bundle that in today's japanese society there are a lot who struggle and live the fuckin gutterpunk, shitty ass lifestyle she speaks of. Japanese society has grown in such a way that if you're a misfit, you fuckin drown in a pool of your own misfit-shit. If you don't want to get a job, wear a black suit, bow to sempai, deal with no-pay overtime and have to go drinking with the boss that you hate...then you rebel...you get by on the skin of your teeth.
Also, in a strange way, the comment about the attitude towards all japanese (pop) music being souless/not-as-good-as-the-west as sort of a racist attitude makes sense. What we should look towards in music is passion...if the artist is truly being honest with their music. SMAP is not honest, but people like B'z (who are cheesy but in a fun way), Judy and Mary, Shiina Ringo, Cornelius/Oyamada Keigo, Pizziacato Five, YMO, Hajime CHitose, UA, and even Asian Kung Fu Generation (i'm biased cause i'm in their latest music video as a creepy foreigner hitting on a japanese guy hahahaha)
Point being, you have to dig...just like in every other country in the world. There's real soul out there. It just comes in different forms from what you're used to.
BTW Archangel, I agree...Beethoven is god. Plus, u seem like a cool guy, so shit, cool out yo!
Addressing hiphop...if you've ever gone to a hiphop show in Japan...you can see some pretty cool shit. There's a band here in Osaka that does this hiphop/hardcore thing with the bass player playing rockabilly style upright. They don't/haven't gotten airplay yet, but there music'll make you bounce. It's no ludacris...but shit...it makes u move.
also..THere's a speedcore band in tokyo with a guy doing the same thing...playing SPEEDCORE on an upright...fuck.
anyway
u said it chilli fresh.
We should all be taking a rather neutral stand on music and not trying to clobber one another with ballsacks. I might come off as this music snob dick hole who knows a shit load about music...and it's true...except I'm not a snob nor a dick hole and I'm passionate about what I do and NEVER EVER EVER! FUCKING EVER! plan on retiring or stopping what I do. I'm a musician...shit...I don't know if a fucking holy ghost ever entered my body...but I know when I've been in the middle of a bass solo on my upright playing jazz or had my hands on a couple of synths backing a rock band on tour in the US that I've almost jizzed my pants... and if that means I was taken off to some spiritual place and the audience felt it too...then fuck yeah! that's some shit!
and if a japanese/indian/english/french/peruvian/argentinian/russian/polish/mongolian/chinese person can do that in their music, then fuck yeah! that's what it's all about.
Music went to shit when the recording industry appeared.
You think every performance of Beethoven's 9th sounded the same? every X show sounded like the album?
this discussion was about music...and the spiritual side of music...it exists...it exists in every art form..whether you call it spiritual or masturbation...it's something magical.
Almost all the pretty, high voiced girls produced by Komuro Tetsuya are trash... if you don't know who he is...look him up...he either destroyed the japanese pop industry or is just a marketing genius...but he's a primary reason for why the majority of the music you hear on the radio is bad...
Avoid Avex Trax (the record label) like the plague.
He's kind of like Malcom McLearen...except he gets to fuck his "johnny rotten" / "Annabella"..then move on to his next victim.
Although...I heard from a tone def friend that the Avex Trax concert she went to was really exciting...but she doesn't care much for good music...
Anyway i'm starting to ramble so
there's my rebuttal.
beepboopbopswoop0101001010110101011
i apoligize for all the unfinished thoughts and lack of focused complete ideas..I'm no thesis/doctorate write...unless it's on staff paper.
Man, not to inject myself into this unnecessarily, and I agree with a lot of what you're saying, but damn, people seem to argue at length about some pretty ultimately meaningless stuff around here...
I respect people who are doing what they are doing and they just do it. You follow that?
I apologize for steppin on toes but you people need to get real, Japan is not drowning in hardship here...dont tell me about Japanese junkies and crime and all that nonsense. I have lived and worked in some of the crapest locations in the WORLD and I am in Japan because it is relatively speaking, low key. I guess after being hospitalized numerous times due to beatings at the hands of skins, north shore boys, straight edgers and various other groups, I am just a sell out puss for moving to Japan and enjoying what I consider to be an extremely tranquil break time for me.
Im sorry, its just not the same here. I think that certain things require certain catalysts for the finished product to have some real feeling and alot of that is just not present on a large enough scale here to produce with the same intensity some of the things I have been exposed too. I just cant forget what I know.
Thats it...
And what the hell is the function of a BBS on MIXI if not to provide a forum for meaningless conversations???
I ADDITION, yes the Damned were cool, but look at other bands reigning supreme at the same time who were not, for example the Exploited, totaly bastards. For every example someone will give here, there is a counter example....
I was brainstorming a little and I have come to the conclusion that I must print a retraction of sorts.
I will concede that yes, RELATIVELY speaking the youth supporting the subcultures of Hip Hop or punk or whatever in Japan are living difficult lives, relatively speaking. So, this would produce angst, depression and a general dislike (ALL BE IT TEMPORARY) for mainstream society and would, in theory, fuel there underground ,musical expression....revolt...whatever.
To those who can frame their arguments in civil English ;
16> chili fresh ; yeah, no one is saying that, and you haven't read the all the comments if you think I'm attacking bundle based on her opinions - that she doesn't give...I'm saying bundle is fucked to dictate to everyone in this topic and previous what they should think - but mainly she chooses to use 'fight talk' for no apparent reason from the get go, and is obviously too chicken to back it up when anyone calls her bluff...so really your comment should be aimed towards bundle, who incidentally is attacking people for liking music...
17> じゃすらん ; mmm you're making arguments based on what bundle says, as chili fresh is - spare ten minutes and read all the comments from number one and find the parts where I said Japanese music has no soul/non japanese aren't allowed to play non Japanese music - feel free to quote me....about 'talking the talk and walking the walk' that had nothing to do with who's is allowed to listen to what music, I was telling bundle that if she wants to post comments in the manner and language she has been doing the last few days she better be prepared to throw down - the only time you address others like that is when you're looking for a fight....physically. Bundle is a coward who wants to insult anyone she feels like and then run away if they call her out. Correct me if I'm wrong but, the music culture bundle claims to be part of wouldn't think that was respectable....would they? would you?
to bundle who I'm going to call cunt from now on ;
cunt> Why do you think I'm an English Teacher?
Catholics aren't technically allowed to use condoms
Why do you think I'm an originator of Grime?
Why do you spell 'you' as 'u' - now that's some real 'street'!
Why do you think I would like GasPanic?
What if I was a homosexual?
well cunt, over the course of your comments you've consistently presented a set of imaginary things I said as fact and then proceded to attack them....I've ignored it up to here in part as I wanted to establish that although you talk fight talk you are definitely not brave enough to fight in person...so all the people you've been randomly attacking can feel free now to call you cunt or coward or shook (← yes another street word there '4 u') whenever you post. Here's some of the great deliberatory points you've made recently;
me taking your word for it, and asking a question ;
So Japanese punk is great? If you say so → Does anyone outside Japan know that band you mentioned? Does anyone outside Japan know 'The Clash', 'NOFX', and 'The Sex Pistols'?
cunt, you said ;
NOFX and the Sex Pistols? hahahha →if that's your definition of soulful music, then u r a sad cunt indeed.
・Who the fuck was talking about soul in connection with those bands except you, cunt? (And you didn't answer the question...)
then you said ;
your sycophantic golden oldies cocksucking tastes?
・Who the fuck said I liked them? And what's wrong with someone liking them - are you telling us what we are and are not allowed to listen to, or dictating what is cool and what isn't?
then you said ;
for someone who tries to talk about 'soulful' music and then judges that music on international profile or record sales is confused to say the least.
・so I didn't say that it was soulful music, so it doesn't follow that I said we should judge soulful music on international sales, I asked why more Japanese bands aren't internationally famous - regardless of genre, cunt...
then you came out with ;
your sceptic semi-racist diatribes... →cos you're a cool white guy who can 'read' english.
・cunt, I've gone from 'semi racist' to all out 'racist', you've just invented that I consider myself superior to Japan and Japanese people in your head so you can vent some anger out about white people and English teachers, go ahead I'll be your punch bag on that - keep giving us blundering generalizations and stereotypes and let people who are able to read more than one comment decide who's got a race issue...cunt.
A 'diatribe' is a long written (that would infer printed cunt) discourse or criticism, where was my sceptic semi-racist diatribe?
The 'read english' comment I made in number 11 was about the above imaginary viewpoints you say I have, cunt. Please read my English. Cunt.
onto ;
of course it's cute the way u paint yourself as an intelligent, yet violent and aggressive homosexual with no morals or qualms, just like a real gangsta.
・cunt, no I think you've painted that picture in your head...I'm not intelligent, but I'd like to gain some intelligent opinion - hence getting involved in/posting these topics...is that not allowed? That and disagreeing with you. I'm not violent, so I don't use fight talk modus operandi because people who do that would be prepared to fight modus operandi (like 'gangsta's, so are you wanting to get across you are 'gangsta'?) - you aren't prepared to fight...but I do talk fight talk when I am prepared to fight - like you aren't. I have some morals, for instance ; the former sentence ; you can't call someone (だいはど for example) a word nazi and then later declare 'cunts who go around expecting ppl to say "what the heck" →these fuckers need it in the face with both barrels.' very 'gangsta' cunt, have you ever fired a shotgun in your life? Would you really do that, or would you chicken out of that too? Anyway, that comment would make you a word nazi wouldn't it cunt - for making an allusion that everyone should to conform to your doctrine of any language goes in public speech or die....yes, not doing that is a pretty strong moral of mine, cunt.
and finally ;
pretending to be tough on the internet
・How tough would a person have to be to qualify as tough cunt? Are you setting the standard on that - get back to me cunt so I can answer better....but the only person pretending to be tough etc here is you in my opinion cunt - picking on men mostly so you can play the "I'm a girl card" if they were to knuckle up (←mo striyat' wuhz 4 u)....if you think I'm a homosexual I'd like to play into that - would you fight a homosexual? Do you even fight? Why do you talk fight talk cunt? Please tell me really, it is giving me a hard on, and it won't go away until I can know why you would chat that shit and not be prepared to fight....?....cunt, please tell me cunt. Or at least justify your way of thinking that it's "the realest thing" to talk like you're ready to fight and then avoid the subject of actually fighting, in real life, like for real...cunt, I'm begging you, tell me cunt...
seriously cunt
please
(thanks in advance cunt)
p/s Unfortunately I'm not an English Teacher. What bad experience did you have with English Teachers cunt? Also you called me a 'wannabe skater' - how many skaters do you know cunt? Pro, am, flow, or just everyday skaters it doesn't matter...Why am I not allowed to skate cunt? What's wrong with skating cunt?
I think the reason why Japanese bands/musicians aren't that big internationally is that they don't sing in English. With the exception of Kyu Sakamoto, I don't think there are that many hits sung in a language outside of English. How many French bands can you think of? Indian? Italian? Since English is for better or worse the de facto international tongue, for a musician to be truly global they basically have to sing in English. Most of the world music that becomes popular or famous is predominantly sung in English. If it is not sung in English it is a regional hit at best.
Having said that though, there are quite a few Japanese pop stars with big followings in Korea and Taiwan. Amuro Namie, Hamazaki Ayumi, Puffy etc etc.. Not great music at all, but shows the growing international appeal of Japanese pop stars...
So maybe your question should be why aren't there any Japanese musicians that are well known in the Western world? I think mainly because of the language barrier. The question could also be asked of French bands or Italin bands or African bands.... it is not a phenomenon known only to Japan. The other reason why Japanese and other nation's bands aren't popular is that the marketing guys are all based in England and the US so they will always favor the bands from their own country and own language- it is just easier and the audience is already there...
I think you have to dig deep and look around for quality since it isn't handed to you from the markting guys at some record label...
Cohiba
perhaps yeah maybe so but what about German bands? Big language barrier but I can name half a dozen mainstream german bands that have become very popular in the US.
In addition, although perhaps its my clique of people, alot of Brazilian music is really popular, again a language barrier.
Anyway the Germans would be the biggest example I can retort with...
And, I think recently the trend seems to be going the other way. Korean and Chinese culture is all over Japan, much mroe than a few years ago. Korean pop in particular and Korean movies, pop culture icons, food, its all a big hit here. Japanese music record sales are down in Hong Kong and Korea.
But does anyone know the band AI NAM??
They are from Thailand and I know there super popular there....I love them. anyway....thank the powers that be for this forum or I would have nothing to do at work but my job....
yea-s i agrees with ya'all
yeehaw!
uh...
cohiba..english is certainly an issue. A lot of the japanese music that I like tends to grind the nerves of my american friends...particularly female friends. They think the girls' voices are too cute and japanese is too bubbly sounding to listen to. A good example might be all the good swedish bands who sing in english...When Komeda released their all swedish sung album, it didn't do so well internationally, despite the quality of music.
That raises an interesting point, do people require words to listen to music?
I got slammed by some hiphop guy for using too much reverb on a vocal in one of my songs. He said my lyrics weren't clear enough...I don't think he realized that the verses were in japanaese and the chorus in english, but that's besides the point.
Archangel=- I see your point. It is all relative. I'm glad I've always some how been able to be neutral in those kind of circles of skins. Japan's standard of living is a lot higher and probably one of the most safest countries in the world.
I guess the little kids in brazil that run around with machetes cutting off tourists hands and fingers to steal their jewelry are certainly more hardcore than anything u'll see in japan...or all those mean scary polish guys that lives in Paris. boooo
...
sorry, i tended to skip over the bundle throw downs.
bundle is a good shit stir-er that's why i tend to side with her. I like shit stirring because it forces people to think and to feel uncombfortable. Then the need to justify ourselves online...behind this facade...these 0's and 1's. SShit, i'll probably get slammed for saying anything, but it's not like i'm gonna end up with a scar or in the hospital from being slammed online. Shit I got slammed in a st.louis newspaper by some gay composer (who only writes musicals about being gay) for scoring the opening theme for a outdoor sports company's deer hunting DVD and TV show series for the outdoor channel...All i can say is he was mad because I was writing music to promote the killing of animals...
to me it was just cash.
But the guy didn't punch me in the gut so I'm not gonna stress it. So I dub bundle a good shit stirrer.
I just don't think all the generalizations are accurate. Most non-japanese on mixi have some japanese skills and are most likely NOT your average english teacher, just trying to score some japanese ass.
I think...
JEFF
-robble robble robble robble robble robble
a-men to the rambling robbles
and pardon me if i've offended you with mine.
i can't name a single german song sung in german that was big in the US.
i can name a few alternative and new wave bands from germany but the songs i know are in english.
Japanese record sales may be down but they were up at some point, which was the original point in that Japanese music whether it is good or not is getting air time overseas.
In order to measure success or popularity you ultimately have to look at the commercial success of the musician, reagrdless of talent. Otherwise, it is difficult to have any consistent benchmark. I might argue that The Clash made great music, but I can't stand today's rap. A dude in South Central may say the exact opposite. Otherwise I could also say that Japanese music is in fact everywhere since I know people all over the world that listen to that stuff.
Brazilian music, I like as well, but when do you really hear a band being in Billboard? Tito Fuentes?
In all this discussion about Japanese music, and Ryuichi Sakamoto was the only name mentioned. We did forget Tei Towa. He's pretty big at clubs and lounges.
DJ honda is also big in the NY club scene.
hey there cohiba,
I can't name any bands that were famous in the UK from Italy, or India...but as far as french bands go I would say 'NTM' and 'The Gypsy Kings' were both given major radio airplay and also musically acclaimed.
I'd like to make a quick qualification here that my point about international fame was two pronged ;
i) Bands respected outside their own domestic market
ii) Bands that significantly sold outside their own domestic market
some people might want to interpret that as 'real' and 'mainstream' music. I don't mind....From what you say, (ii) is a direct function of marketing capital (nowadays), and largely dependant on if the lyrics are sung in English or not...Yes I suppose I'd have to agree. Just a quick one though, the largest music market, the US, is currently booming with 'Reggaeton' a spanish language hybrid from Puerto Rico. I'd say that not all the people buying those records, or listening to the radio channels are Spanish speakers of Puerto Rican decent...
I admit I know DJ Honda and I think various Japanese Djs are fairly well known.
Next...onto the Germans...this is sort of a topic in and of itself, but I just want to point out a few examples.
First, how I am classifying popular, basically whether or not that got air time on MTV. MTV makes me feel sleepy so I dont watch it but, Im just using it as a bench of sorts.
Nina Hagen, East German, she made hits in both English and German.
Rammstein. emassed a huge following nearly overnight in American singing almost entirely in German. They sold out arenas in America.
BAP, a well Known German pop band released singles and even a couple albums that were well recieved in the AMericas as well.
All three of these examples aired on MTV, with Rammstein probably being the most well known, and the most annoying with there hit DU HAST. But MUDER, ICH WILL etc did well too. In fact I think they just won the BEST SELLING ARTIST AROUDN THE WORLD germany award....50 cent also won this award...obviouly not for germany.
My point is they are a power house, making loads of money and hugely well known all over the planet and they sing in German...and I like there Engel alot actually...
Mixi thank you again for giving me a reason to waste time at the office.
Nina Hagen's hits in the US were in English.
Rammstein never heard of them. will google.
lets not forget Beethoven Bach and Mozart.
looking back, i do recall some german bands, most of the ones i liked are not major airwave hoggers though, but i do admit that the germans have a decent following but nothing at the level of a Rolling Stones or even the Cure or a Michael Jackson. and Germany is the exception to the rule, the pointis still valid for most other countries. interesting that German is considered to be the sister language to english. so maybe it doesn't sound as foreign to an English speaker.
also Spanish is the seconde most spoken language in the US. in some parts of the south and LA it is the predominant language....
I can think of 4 Japanese pop singers that have English releases... PInk Lady in the 70's (even had a US TV show), Utada - crap all crap, Seiko Matsuda- sang a duet with some dude from NKOTB, Akina Nakamori- not quite all crap, but can't listen to the entire disc.
Utada made a little bit of commotion in the US with some club popularity. but none were really chart successes.
i don't want to be rude but you sound like a dick.
puffing up your chest about how many times you got beaten up in america and then saying how that makes the music better than anything in japan, that's just lame, man.
and your condescending post about how japanese kids have hard lives, but only temporarily, well, that's just straight up ignorant.
i think you are only talking about your own life, right?
you hung out in the hardcore scene in the US but you don't in Japan, so you think it's different right?
that's pretty nearsighted. what if japanese kids went and stayed in a rich white suburb in the US and came back to japan and said, "well, they don't have any hardship over there"? they would sound stupid and frankly, you do too.
we all know america has a very high standard of living and we could easily see kids who get a job and go straight after a bit of 'rebeling' in their teens.
in fact, i would say most american teenagers go through the same phases you claim 'wannabe' japanese kids do.
the examples you give of your hardcore life sound pretty underground to me and there are certainly those types of people in japan too, but because you don't know them you jump to the conclusion that they don't exist.
you seem not to believe bundles comments about junkies in japan, for example. well, i've seen plenty of shocking things in that scene here, if you wanna compete 'between your country and mine' but that's not really about the music, is it?
stop talking about yourself and the inane comments you make about kids you see in shibuya. i could go to any mall in america and do the same thing.
oh, and to that guy that seems to like calling girls, 'cunts', you're just an asshole.
Chilli....I think your assuming Im American and your assuming I grew up in America, both of which are incorrect.
Anyway its ok, I think I made it clear that I said people have it hard in different ways and in there way, yeah its hard for them genuinly be an upper crust American fella or a middle class Japanese girl or some poor guy drunk in a ditch in Argentina...Its all relative, thats what I said.
Whats more, untill you sit down with me face to face and a bit of Q and A insues, I dont think your really qualified to say Im a dick or Im not or whatever. However surer, if you want to just be rude like alot of other people in forums, go for it. Have a blast.
I have actually been involved in the hardcore scene here, and I didnt comment on it because I just didnt feel it was very hardcore, comparatively speaking. I will give it to the guys that are going from Osaka to Tokyo to whever ever grinding it out though, I know a thing or two about that, its rough. I give them there due for that. But just from what I saw, it wasnt as hard, it wasnt as raw and it just wasnt at the level I was exposed to elsewhere. If you can recommend some down and dirty in Tokyo, please do, I will go check it out.
That isnt a sarcastic comment either. I will be more than willing to go to a couple shows and report back, tell you my thoughts. Or hey, you can just keep hurling insults based on a bbs. Your call.
And I think Nina Hagen had a couple hits in German in America as well.
why would i recommend something for you that wasn't 'at the level' you were used to, you elitist prick?
i don't want to be your friend or prove to you that japan can 'rock as hard' as where ever you think is cool.
it's pretty clear that no-one needs to sit down face to face with you to know you are a hardcore bore who judges music by how macho it is. hell, you probably have a tattoo, too.
ummm....yeah, i guess i shouldn't have bothered, but i thought you were someone into music, but, ahhh, yeah, turns out you are more into yourself, i guess, wow.
what does 'involved in the hardcore scene' mean to you? cos at the moment, i can't believe that would amount to much except picking up bitches at lame s+m fashion shows...