In both Japan and the US there's a great demand for body parts needed for transplants. Some of the major ones include kidneys, liver, and heart. In the US (and probably in Japan too) it's illegal for a person to sell their own organs, although it is legal to donate them upon their death. Obviously a person would not sell their own heart or liver, but they could sell one kidney and still live.
There's always a long list of people waiting for donated parts, but the supply will never meet the demand out there if we rely solely on donated parts. Body parts from accident/murder victims can't be used unless concent was given by the victim prior to death. One may be able to bypass this if family members are able to say that the donation of organs was the deceased person's will.
Anyway, I want to know what people think about the legal trade of organs. One of the up-sides may be that paying for organs (of both living and deceased people) may give people more of an incentive to part with potentially life saving organs. A down-side may be that people who need the transplants the most may end up not being able to afford them. Currently in the US people with the greatest need for transplants get put at the top of the list. If people are able to buy the organs then lives will be saved, but it may be in order of wealth, not urgency.
>ひろき(Hiroki)
Thanks for your input, but there was just one thing I wasn't sure about where your stood regarding the sale of body parts. People are allowed to sell blood, semen, and eggs for monetary profit, and these are human "body parts" as well. Do you think it's wrong for the sale of these items also? If not, then how would a kidney or liver differ from selling blood or semen in terms of the ethics of selling them?
>ひろき(Hiroki)
You bring up a good point about the reproducibility of blood, semen, and eggs compared to organs like kidneys. Then how about a liver? You can cut a liver into two parts, a smaller part and a larger part, and you can leave the larger part in the adult and transplant the smaller one into a child. Both parts will gradually regenerate into a full liver. So would transplanting a liver differ from a kidney? And would it differ from blood, seeing how although it is somewhat reproducible, it takes a much longer time?
There are actually stem cells found in all tissues, including kidneys and hearts, and even our skin. There are most likely stem cells in our blood as well, which originate in our bone marrow. If these stem cells could be triggered to develope into organs, then do you think we should reconsider the standing of blood transfusions? Or maybe make the regulations on stem cell treatment and/or organ transplants more lenient?
Well I was kinda hoping that maybe I could just start the debate and listen to what all the other people had to say, but I guess I'll just voice my opinino to fill in the void :)
I'm not a religious person, so it's very easy for me to think of things in an economical and down to earth manner. To me the body is not a temple of God, but neither is it simply a vessel for our "souls". I see it as a very fine tuned machine that has some expendable and exchangeable parts, and eventually we all break down.
We're strange as a species because we go out of our way to do things that save others of our species, with no real benefit on our own part. We donate blood for people we have no genetic link with, and we'll most likely never gain anything other than emotional gratification by performing certain acts of charity. But because there is no real physical gain, a lot of people are hesitant to sacrifice a part of our time, or us, to help others.
In the States we have an organ doner program, where in the event of an accidental death/murder a person's organs, if healthy, can be given to people in need. A lot of people don't like this because even after we're dead we want to keep everything, especially if we're not getting (or our families aren't getting) anything in return. Because of this not everyone participates in the program and there's a great deficit in terms of the number of organs available.
If a program was instated where people could sell their organs once they are deceased and have the profits go to their loved ones, or if a person could sell a kidney or their bone marrow for cash, there would be a more than ample supply of donors out there. People need money, and people are willing to part with many things so long as you pay them the right price. So if it's not going to kill them, and if they're willingly selling their body parts, then there should be nothing illegal about it.
Another argument I have to support the sale of body parts is that the hospital makes a killing off of organs. You're actually paying the hospital and buying the organ in need when you get a transplant. Did you think the $100,000 price tag was just to pay the doctors for their skills? No, probably about a quarter of that is the price of the organ. So if the hospitals are able to make a profit off of organs, then why not the donors? Of course this might make the operation more costly, but is anyone really willing to put a price on a child's life?
There are a lot of potential probelems if organs become available on the market, but I don't see any of those issues as being impossible to resolve. Besides, that's what we have brilliant and over payed people in this world for: to figure out how to make things work.
If an individual doesn't want to participate in the sale of their oragans due to any reason (whether it be religious or personal distaste) then that's every person's right to do (or not do) so. But I'm sure that a lot of these people would think differently if they were put on a waiting list, and there were still another 3000 names to go until it was their turn to have a second chance at life.
So, I say yay, but give people the liberty to choose what they want to do. I think it would be a good idea to make it so that it's not mandatory to get money for it too, so that you really can just donate the organ for no profit if you're just a super saintly person.
>harefumam
I definitely see where you're coming from, and I would hate for people to make speedy and faulty judgment calls due to greed. Life, at any point, should be taken priority over money. Of course if the person is brain dead, and if it's the will of the patient and/or family members to have his/her life ended, then that is alright with me. If after the patient is deceased and the body parts were to be sold, then so long as all moral grounds were covered then I don't see anything wrong with that too. Especially with patients who have an unbelievably high amount of medical debt due to hospitalization, the selling of organs may be the best way to save the surviving family members from years of additional burden.
Hi, everybody. It's nice to meet you.
1stly I'd like to show my point of view.
Of course saving life instead of money is one of the debateble point. Rather say saving life is no bad.
However I suppose that main core issue is whether individuals have right to earn money by selling their body parts. That is because, in my knowledge, even the status quo some case of "alive organ transportations" have been taken, for instance among family.
You may think it's quite difficult to image in Japan, but please image in slum in the U.S. There are some people who may have good organ but money. Hence this issue concerns about the poor rather than for recipient.
Therefore this topic is clash between individual right & commodification of human beings, I consider.
Sorry for interrupting your argument.
2ndly I'd like to show my stance.
I objectively affirm selling body as far as it's enough informed choice for example contract, risk, & compensation. No harm, huh? It may be forgivable & legitimate choice.
On the contrary, personaly, I don't wanna people to sell their body parts.