ログインしてさらにmixiを楽しもう

コメントを投稿して情報交換!
更新通知を受け取って、最新情報をゲット!

ENGLISH DEBATE ON SOCIAL TOPICコミュのjapan apologizes to asia

  • mixiチェック
  • このエントリーをはてなブックマークに追加
i found this news article on yahoo (http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20050815/ts_nm/japan_war_anniversary_dc) that finally asks what china and other countries have been protesting for: an apology.

will this be the end to the clashing in china and korea? what's your take on this event?

コメント(21)

Is this the first time a Japanese premier has issued an official apology to China, Korea and other Asian nations that Japan mistreated during WWII?
i don't think so but the other countries are acting like it hasn't been done. this is just my view. i do not know the entire history on this subject.
I don't think it is our first official apology. The mayor of Hiroshima has given out his condolences out 10 years ago...which sadly Korea decided NOT to report to their people (did anyone see that program on TV a while ago?). I bet this BS will never end. Japan has officially apologized over the past few decades, paid reparation, and whatnot. And our leader even gave out apologizes today and this is what we get....

"The Japanese government and politicians must stop the beautification and worship of war criminals and repent and apologize for past aggression and criminal acts," said South Korean Park In-joo outside a restored prison once used by Japan."

I don't think most of our politicians beautify nor worship war criminal. These people are just taking the minority opinion and making it as if it is a major opinion.

I myself have studied some history, and I know all the horrible crimes our country has committed in the past. And its not only during WWII, but way back in the Edo period as well to import art.

I really just wish we all could get along. And IMO, Koizumi should have done this his first year he was elected as Prime Minister.
i know this isnt in English, but check this out...

http://headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20050815-00000203-yom-pol
I definitely agree with ブンブン on this topic on several points. Yeah, it is BS that China and S. Korea aren't accepting the numerous apologies made by the Japanese government, and it most likely will never be fully resolved. How long do these people want to live in the past? Probably indefinitely.
I think one of the biggest issues that China and S. Korea have against Japan is the whole deal with the Japanese history text books not mentioning certain lings like the Manchuria massacre and other events that took place during the war. Seriously though, you can't write everything into a text book, that would make the thing a thousand pages too long for any one year course to cover.
And as for the misconception of the glorifying of the war criminals, this is absolutely absurd and is completely a fabrication of the Chinese and S. Koreans. Those tombs for the war dead are just like those found in Arlington Cemetary: they're there to honor those who fought for and died for the country. It's not like these people went to war because they wanted to kill, and so there should be no reason why their honor should be tainted simply because of a little grudge that the other east asians aren't willing to let go. If there's no problem with George Bush visiting the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, then there should be no big deal about Koizumi visiting Yasukuni. And ブンブン, I agree that certain things should have been done a little sooner, but one of the first appearances of Koizumi to these grounds was done despite quite a bit of opposition from other influencial political leaders, so at least he went out of his way, against his friends, to do what's right. So you have to give him a little credit for that, right?
めいさん>
thats the article i was looking for! sorry, i was in a hurry and couldnt find an English one. That whole cabinet members going to Yasukuni and stuff...thats just ignorant.

ハヤトさん>
IMO (in my opinion), I think Koizumi is a wonderful PM. He's probably one of the few Japanese politians who can stand for himself instead of 'just go with the flow' or have that sometimes retarded Japanese 調和 stuff. We need a leader like that in future. So yes, I do give him lots of credit; especially following through his own beliefs. However agreeing with his ideology...well thats another issue.

ah, the issue of textbooks. Like you said, its impossible to cram all that into a textbook. If they want the whole truth, might as well tell us what REALLY happened in the Tiananmen Square Incident :p. Textbooks are really biased; this is an undeniable fact and I really think we need to teach our kids what we really did in the past. For example (this is grotesque so the weak hearted should skip this...) I think we should teach them that war generals had a mass slaughter contest of who can chop off the head of a Chinese in a given hour, and other events. Or else, kids are going to grow up that Japan was the victim of WWII.

But in the end...if we're gonna go parallel about what happened in the past indefinitely despite our efforts, then maybe its time to change the way we are trying to resolve this issue.
>ブンブン
Like you said, biased textbooks are always going to be a problem, but as always, history is written by the victor (or the guy financing the production of the textbooks). It was a problem in Iraq with Hussein, and it still is a problem in the US (although many issues are mentioned, but still idealized). It might help if teachers promoted students to think outside of the textbook and have them do reports and presentations on things that aren't mentioned in the textbooks, to get them to realize what else actually happened, and what other views are out there.
I am happy to get to this community.

War-related things have been controversial for many years. Each country has history of its own version; they somehow try to think of what they did as the right thing. This may result in sticking points as we see on everyday news.

I was very surprised when I read an article on the atomic bomb dropped in Hiroshima on Time magazine. It said that the atomic bombs were used to STOP THE WAR, and they SAVED MANY LIVES. It can be right but we are the victims of these a-bombs so that we never say that the a-bombs saved lives, but say they killed many precious lives. (I do not think the bombs used to save lives at all as well.) This is a kind of excuse for them to use these terrible weapons. However, this article gave me something important. Each country has its own interpretation for history and we can see one thing from various view points.

So it is important to know the other side of history. We have to see our country from both view points: the only victim of atomic bombs and at the same time, the victimizer. The point is that we have to keep them in the balance.

Mutual understanding is crucial to solve a string of problems so that we can comprehend both positions, I think. In order to attain this, Japan has to accept more students from these Asian countries than it does now. There are many students who want to study in Japan but Japanese higher education system is the obstacle for them to come. I think it is very difficult for them to get diploma here. I have a Chinese friend who wanted to study in Japan as a graduate student but he had to give up it because of the barriers. However, when these people who study in Japan take over higher positions in their countries, our relations would be more stable and tight because they know our point of view and we know from them their point of view. Once we have a friend from a different country, we get to want to know more about the country.

Sorry that what I wrote here somewhat deviate from the original topic. What I wanted to say most is that we have to think why they denounce Koizumi’s visit to Yasukuni shrine; without mutual understanding we cannot understand it completely, I think.

Thank you very much.
With the Bush example I wasn't necessarily saying that there's a direct connection between the US and Korea/China, I'm just saying that people in general should have a similar view on each event.

I'm not sure how many people would say that Japan didn't invade China, at least most Japanese I know acknowledge it. There is an aspect of defence and breaking away from the overcontrolling activities of the US that was part of Japan's invasion of foreign countries, which can't be omitted either. Now whether that makes it OK to have killed many innocents, it obviously doesn't. But everyone has to realize that nations commit "crimes" and attack other countries for a reason. It just happens to be that Japan's reasons are never mentioned in any text books (especially ones in the US, where it makes it seem like Japan just started invading Asian countries and attacked Pearl Harbor for no reason).

What needs to just happen is to have everyone put the past in the past and leave it there. Yes, many people were killed, and yes, many lives were ruined, but that's not my problem nor do I care to comfort any Koreans or Chinese for something that I didn't do. Most of the people who were in charge of these activities are now dead, so it's not like they can apologize for what they did either. Every group of people has committed a ghastly act in their past, but that's no reason for anyone in the present (who is nothing like their ancestors) to make up and repent. I mean, most of the people who are complaining about Japan weren't even born yet when these things took place, and in many case their parents weren't either. They need to realize that the world has changed, and that Japanese people aren't like that anymore (well, not like the majority were like that in the first place, but...).
So I would like to ask you a question from a different viewpoint.

Do you think these Asian countries will stop complaining completely if Japanese leaders abandon visiting Yasukuni shrine?

I am very happy to hear your ideas.

Thank you.
>み@る
I wish it were that simple, but I'm can say with nearly 100% certainty that they won't stop complaining just because politicians stop visiting Yasukuni. People who want to go out of their way to make themselves the victims will always have a backup excuse to constantly keep themselves in the spotlight until they feel that their cause has been won. It's sad how a lot of ignorant people are being brainwashed by government propaganda, but this is hardly the first time in any country.

>Hiroki
>I imagine there is no "war criminal" in Tomb of the Unknown Soldier of US
Well as the name implies, all of the people buried there are unidentified soldiers, so (although probably not) there could potentially be someone in there who did commit a war crime. Not a really important point though.
And you made a good point about the US being victorious in WWII and that's why there weren't any American war criminals. The man in charge of the bombardment and burning down of many of the major cities in Japan (and as a result probably killing more people than the people who dropped the atomic bomb), said himself that had the US lost then he would have most very likely been charged as a war criminal. So at least some people are realizing that winning doesn't automatically clean your hands of your guilt, which is good because the fact that he admitted these things it made me feel at least a little better about the guy. He at least had the guts to come out and admit what he did was an injustice against civilians. But that's what the Japanese government's been doing too! So the fact that the Koreans and Chinese are still hanging onto this grudge simply indicates to me that they aren't able to let go of the past and are stuck in a pointless stalemate.
And the thing they need to understand is that the politicians have never intended on revering the war criminals buried at Yasukuni, but rather to honor those people in general who served and died for the country. It's unfortunate that some of those good people buried there are kind of guilty by association due to the war criminals buried there with them. At this point in time most Japanese won't deny the massacres (although they might have a few years back) and have apologized. They're all close, powerful countries that could really get more out of each other if they just stopped pestering Japan over stuff that should just be water under the bridge. Pardon my French, but China and Korea just need to get that stick out of their ass and stop promoting the hate amongst their people. Hate has never gotten anyone anywhere, and hate and misunderstanding was most likely a big part of the massacres. So by promoting the same anti-whoever sentiments, the Korean and Chinese governments are no better than the officers in charge of the murders of thos civilians in WWII.
Okay, first off, we have to understand that we
are talking about two countries (China & Korea)
that have no freedom of expression. Their lives
are controlled by the state, manipulated and brought
up to become promoters of hate.
Of course they'll complain forever the "pain" that
we so have apparently caused, regardless of the
Yasukuni Shrine or textbook issues (which reminds
me, ハヤトsan, the term "buried" is not adequate
considering the fact that the Yasukuni Shrine is not
a burial or a cemetary. Lost ones have been enshrined
to protect the country as "kami").

To get back on topic, no I do not believe that this
"apology" will serve to stop the endless bitching by
these two countries. As stated above, Japan has
already formally apologized countless times and payed
billions of dollars (regardless of the San Francisco
Treaty that concluded that Japan had finished it's
responsiblities for the war - 50 years ago).

If you look around the globe, war has shaped the history
of many countries. In Europe, France and England had
countless battles, but present day they maintain a
healthy relationship (at least more so than Japan and
Korea/China). What makes them so different? They are
not brought up to be soldiers of hate, and they are matureenough to understand what has happened has happened and that is that.
Sometimes, it is difficult to tell..

When Japan speaks the words of sorrow...
Does it mean "applogize"?

The words of sorrow is different from "appologizing"

It is recepient's decision to judge whether "appologizing" or just the words of sorrow.
since we are having an intellectual discussion, shouldn't viewpoints from all parties be taken into account?
with that said, thought i would share numerous articles.

http://times.hankooki.com/lpage/nation/200505/kt2005051019365411950.htm

http://www.china.org.cn/english/international/139035.htm
(on china.org, there are tons of related article links since it is not consolidated like the one from hankooki.com)

http://www.etaiwannews.com/Taiwan/Politics/2005/08/16/1124155761.htm


disclaimer:
i am not agreeing, disagreeing, condoning, nor disapproving anything. (including opinions in this discussion)

ログインすると、残り7件のコメントが見れるよ

mixiユーザー
ログインしてコメントしよう!

ENGLISH DEBATE ON SOCIAL TOPIC 更新情報

ENGLISH DEBATE ON SOCIAL TOPICのメンバーはこんなコミュニティにも参加しています

星印の数は、共通して参加しているメンバーが多いほど増えます。

人気コミュニティランキング