I remember that a few months ago there was a topic about teachers in Japan who got in trouble for refusing to sing Japan's national anthem, so when I saw this topic about a child in the Southern US who refused to say the pledge of allegiance, I thought I would post it and see what people on Mixi thought.
In many grammar schools in the United States, children are expected to daily stand and recite the pledge of allegiance. However, this child, Will Phillips, refused to do so because while the final line of the pledge describes the US as a place "with liberty and justice for all," Will feels that this is untrue because the Gay and Lesbian Communities are not treated equally.
While the boy was not specifically punished, he was sent to the principal's office after getting into an argument with his substitute teacher. Constitutionally, he has every right not to say the pledge if he does not want to. However, the school refuses to apologize to him, and he is now being bullied in school by some people who disagree about gay rights.
What do you think? Have you (Americans) ever refused to say the pledge of allegiance? How do you think this would have been handled at your school? For those of you that felt the teachers in Japan should have been punished for refusing to sing the Japanese national anthem, do you also feel this boy should be punished for not reciting the American pledge of allegiance? I'm curious to hear your opinions.
Pledge of Allegiance... If you pledge allegiance to the United States of America or to any nation, then there will always be someone who take advantage of that pledge, that is, the people in power. That's the trick of Pledge of Allegiance.
I'm not american and we didn't had patriotic pledges or ceremonies in our schools, though some christianic stuff (which I would refuse today).
I think the boy is very thoughtfull for his age, connecting the pledge with the state of the nation he lives in. As civilian and naturally as underaged, who juristical doesn't apply to the term of capacity, he is not bound to any contract or regulation like a teacher or employee would be. Since that there would be also no base at all for punishing him in any form.
Last but not least, I think children should not be influenced by politics, religion or any other direction. They should get an neutral view on things and figure it out themself.
Personally, I like the pledge. It's one of the few times we actually recognize America for what it REALLY is: a republic (not a democracy)
Having said that, I don't like the idea of any representative of the government (in this case, a teacher) forcing anyone to recite a pledge of any sort. I believe this kid has the right not to say the pledge regardless of his reasoning.
ポコちゃん : The pledge of allegiance isn't a song. We have the national anthem, which we are supposed to stand and sing the star spangled banner, which really only happens at sporting events and political inaugurations anyway, and then there is the pledge of allegiance. it is simply a few lines that we have to stand up and say every day when we are young in grammar school (They don't make us do this in high school or college, And we don't ahve to do it anywhere except in grammar school). The pledge goes:
I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America
and to the republic for which it stands;
One nation, [under God], indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Kamui: For once I think I agree with you, lol.
However, i think the comments left by people on that article are very disturbing.
I think the parents should definitely make sure to inform the teachers at the beginning of each school year that their child will not participate. That would clear up any problems with pushy teachers.
First, the kid is very articulate and stated his opinion well...
second he mentioned that he grew up around a lot of gay people (in Arkansas???)
I kept noticing his dad (Anybody ever hear of "bear culture"...)
and I almost fell on the floor when he said that the kids called him a "gay wad" and John Roberts asked him what a gay wad is...
I also liked his father's facial reactions during the interview.
Actually, it is not unheard of for some people to refuse to stand for the pledge, sometimes because of religious issues, sometimes personal... It looks like what happened was that the teacher taunted him and rather than raising the issue with his father, continued to taunt him in front of the class, so he told her to jump off a bridge... He apologized in a written letter... I suspect that both he and the teacher were wrong. - - but we don't know the teacher's side of the story... What should have happened is that if the school had a policy, he should have been asked to go to the principal or disciplinarian's office to discuss the matter, and if a resolution couldn't be reached, the father should have been called... If it got to the point where the incident happened 4 days in a row, I guess the teacher was just taunting him.
Whatever the case: I think the father should be proud of the kid for what he did - - assuming he did it on his own... (How did it make the news... hmmmmm...) That said, if I was one of the other kids in the class and that age, I'd have to admit, I'd probably have called him a gay-wad too... Its part of being a kid...
エディー : Well, the article linked to mentions that the case made the news because after the school refused to apologize his mother started telling everyone and put it up on twitter. If the substitute was literally taunting him for 4 days, that sounds like grounds for termination, given that students get enough bullying from their peers and do not need it from their teachers. After all, just last year two American students took their own lives because of similar harassment while the teachers and staff did nothing about it...
I am not an Amwerican, but I strongly believe everyone has the right to NOT stand up and recite the Pledge of Allegiance. I feel exactly the same about the Japanese national anthem. If you choose to recite/sing it, great, but it should be up to you and only you.
It is especially true in the country that prides itself on its "freedom for all."
BTW when was "under God" added to the Pledge of Allegiance?
#10
"Under God" was added in the early 1950's. Supposedly, it was to compel school children to acknowledge the role of God in the America's founding. President Eisenhower admitted this when he signed the legislation. It was also supposed to be a counter to "godless" Communism which everyone feared at the time.
Personally, I acknowledge America's religious heritage, but I think adding "under God" reeks of government pushing a particular religious viewpoint.
I think the boy here shows quite a bit of foresight, and the quote in the article makes quite a bit of sense: "He's probably more aware of the meaning of the pledge that a lot of adults".
The pledge in question harkens to the very core of American. The writer of the pledge, Francis Bellamy, had lived through the Civil War and had seen the nation's fabric torn. Doubtlessly, he was a man who loved his nation, and wanted to in some way encapsulate who and what we are as Americans in a brief way, expressing who we are and what we are about.
Interestingly: This ended up becoming part of a marketing campaign for flag sales. I doubt many people recall that bit. At any rate, the words Bellamy composed struck a chord in the public and ushered in a
tradition of speaking of our fealty to the nation.
Personally, I think that not saying the pledge is a bit like boycotting Valentine's Day: it's your right, but expect people to be quite surprised by the result, particularly at a young age. I would argue that while it is essential for children to be educated about their country, in order to understand the context in which they are found, and in order to foster that country's growth forward by understanding its foundations, many of the basic principles for the United States of America are found in our Bill of Rights; under one or several of these, people may elect to abstain from certain social functions.
Often, when people go against a certain accepted tradition, they are ridiculed in some way by their peers and others of dissenting opinion. Here, the substitute became disturbed because the boy was exercising his freedom--and in his actions he was doing something unthinkable for her (a nice example of cognitive dissonance).
Through the decades, the pledge has gained a certain amount of synonymy with being American: if you say the pledge, you are one of us. If you don't, you're not one of us. As kids, we learn the pledge and a few other songs which help reinforce that patriotic notion of our nation's soul. Schools are tools used to introduce this sense of history and culture.
Should the school apologize? No. The student was not harmed in any way by the school. the principal "made him look up information about the flag and what it represents", which is consistent with their role as an educator. The substitute should not be forced to apologize, either. That the boy has been ridiculed by certain peers is unfortunate; however, growing of age in most cultures is all about dealing with ridicule and adversity; I would argue that many of these bullies will later in life realize the simple profundity of this boy's actions and feel ashamed that they ridiculed him for expressing, in the most basic terms, his Americanness. His decision to speak out about his beliefs will, however, force all those around him to really pause and consider what the pledge means, and what it means to refuse to say it--and, after all, whether we need to update tradition.
Well i just said it anyways. Since the took out "Under God" from the pledge i dont see the point in saying it. :/ Thats is news to me though. I have never heard of someone getting in trouble from not saying the pledge. So i would have sued the school. Haha
The funny thing is: is the pledge necessary?
For example, if I don't pledge, am I exempted
for being "loyal" to the US and permitted to spy
for north Korea? Of course not! The pledge is just
a patriotic display... It is meant to help forge a sense
of a national identity.... which leads to the question
of being forced to say "under god" -- because the constitution
does not say that to be a u.s. citizen you must believe
in god.... it does talk about liberty and justice (for most)...
Ironically, I'm surprized "states rights" people don't take
offense to indivisible...)
Regarding Twitter, I think with stories like this publicists
often lurk in the background... It's a great story though...
I feel bad for "bubble boy"...
千望詩:>>The substitute should not be forced to apologize,
The substitute herself ridiculed the boy, not just the other kids, so yes, she should be forced to apologize.
Should the principal apologize? Well...that's up for debate, but in any case, the kid should not have had to look up information about the flag or what it represents. Why? The kid made his stance very clear: the pledge of allegiance claims that the flag and the nation represent that our country has liberty and justice for all. It does not. It is a fact that it does not. That is the reason why he did not participate. Forcing the kid to do research was completely pointless, considering it doesn't affect his reasons for not participating. Therefore, it's NOT consistent with the principal's rule of educator. To have been consistent as an educator, he would have sent the kid back to class to continue his actual education, and told the substitute to get over it before it turned into a big deal, since legally the kid was in the right. But does he necessarily have anything to apologize for...not really.
>>That the boy has been ridiculed by certain peers is unfortunate; however, growing of age in most cultures is all about dealing with ridicule and adversity; I would argue that many of these bullies will later in life realize the simple profundity of this boy's actions and feel ashamed that they ridiculed him for expressing, his Americanness.
Again, one look at the comments on the article I posted is more than enough to prove how wrong that idea is. Regardless is the fact that schools DO have a moral and in some cases legal obligation to protect students from bullying. If a student complains that they are being bullied, the bully is supposed to get into some kind of trouble.
Considering that as I mentioned before, two students at different american school decided to commit suicide because they were constantly teased in similar ways, that the mother of one of the kids regularly visited the school's principal, and yet the school still refused to do anything that could have prevented the kids' deaths, it is quite obvious that the school should have done something, and that the substitute should apologize.
You mention the role of educator. The principal was right because he tried to "teach" the kid. The substitute was not wrong (even though she herself was a bully) because she was "teaching" the kid that you sometimes have to deal with crap.
That's not really how education is supposed to work. All educators are supposed to teach any children in their charge how to become responsible, respectful, functional members of society. John Dewey, one of the most influential of educational thinkers, went so far as to claim that the subject matter is less important than that the kids grow up learning to be mature and responsible.
By letting a kid be bullied because he had a legitimate concern about the state of the nation, by trying to tell the kid that he was wrong just because the teacher disagreed with his political opinion, by bullying a kid herself, is she really educating ANYONE? No, obviously not. If anything, all she did was 'teach' the other kids in the classroom that it's okay to make fun of people. That is NOT consistent with her role as an educator.
First; I'll admit that I only read half the comments here. I should say that the ones I read seemed rational (even the ones I dont really agree with). Kamui is rather calm in a topic about America. Just teasing ya man.
Anyhow, I am American and in my area we were expected to say it right through 12th (final) grade each day in the morning. I refused to say it due to the "under God" part from about 7th or 8th grade.
The Supreme Court recognizes a student's right to refuse to say it but of course that doesn't mean anything outside of the judicial system.
I was never reprimanded formally for not saying the pledge but I was given a lot of dirty looks and was taken aside more than once by one teacher or another.
Honestly this kind of treatment probably radicalized me more than I would have become otherwise. By 10th grade I was wearing anarchy symbols and up-side-down American flags to school. haha
School is an extremely conformist environment (and the school administrators do everything they can to keep it that way). I couldn't tolerate it myself. Though I was a gifted student (and participated in several extra-curricular programs) I quit school in my final year when I could no longer take it.
I applaud this student for taking the stance he did. I do wonder how much of it was his own idea (as his father seems supportive) but either way good for him.
Sorry I wrote far too much but this is a topic that still touches me, 10 years removed from high school.
Shouta> Heya mate ;) I think I expressed this in another thread some time before, but I'll just do it again then. There is something realy interesting - and that's a large mentality difference between the USA and Europe. While media talks about "the West" or "the western world" one would get the picture that North America and Europe would be in generally the same. We wear same/similar clothes style, drive same cars, eat same things, like same movies and Sitcoms, have similar form of state, etc.
But in the way of thinking and reasoning, in the way of religious beliefs, in the way of national holidays and national identification there is a notable difference. I am tempted to believe that the two great wars in Europe and the time after changed the way that Europeans thought about their countries and societies. With the exception of French people I don't know any European whith strong patriotic feelings toward his/her country (this changes only during sport events like Soccer world championship). Same is about Religion.
Shouta: I agree, school IS pretty conformist. Fortunately, my grammar school was not too bad. I used to say the pledge of allegiance every day without ever actually thinking about what it meant. Then one day I noticed one of my classmates was not saying it. When i asked her about it, she said that she didn't like to say the pledge of allegiance, and that with all of the things that were wrong with our country, she felt as though the pledge was a lie, and to say it would be selling out her own beliefs (not in those exact words, but...yeah).
We were about 10 or 11 at the time, and after she said that, I thought about it, and I agreed. So I stopped saying the pledge. It feels like saying the pledge would be like agreeing with all of the bad things the country does. One nation, under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all? Is that supposed to be a joke? Aside from the various religious, the north and the south disagree on a lot of issues. So do conservatives and liberals. So how are we indivisible? Liberty and justice for all? Who is this all? The rich white men? Women are still not treated equally, nor are gays, hispanics, african-americans, the disabled...So why the hell should I (or the kid in the article) be forced to stand up and recite a lie?
It was noted that the kid was made to research the meaning of the pledge and flag. Why? He obviously understood it more than most people. If anything the rest of the class should be doing the research.
PS. 千望詩 said the kid was not harmed in any way. This is untrue. He was removed from class and sent to the principal's office. Then he was forced to do pointless work which was a direct result of being sent out of class. This is a punishment.
If students fight in the class, they are removed and sent to the principal's office to write letters explaining what they did wrong.
If students throw a tantrum or break something, they are removed and sent to the principal's office to write letters explaining what they did wrong.
Sounds to me like the kid in the article WAS harmed; he was punished (and bullied by the 'teacher'), and had his education disrupted for doing something he was completely in the right for.
Thanks for the info. Yes, I agree that the addition of "under God" reeks of the government instilling in its people the idea that Christianity is the nation's primary religion.
#22
> instilling in its people the idea that Christianity is the nation's primary religion.
I wouldn't say "Christianity" since Jews and Muslims also believe in "God" -- and I haven't yet met any of them who are offended by "under God", but it still alienates those who worship Buddha, multiple gods, etc., or are atheists.
#23: Even though 'under god' might not offend jews or muslims,
we know what is REALLY meant. When I was young, I did have a jewish friend who was offended. Partly because of the presupposition that "under god" was specifically referring to Christianity, as it IS the US' primary religion.
Sorry - gonna have to disagree. It REALLY means "God" and it's up to the person reciting it as to how it's perceived. There is no "wink-wink, nod-nod" going on as to it "really" meaning something else.
If they had wanted it to mean specifically "Christianity", it would have stated "under Jesus". If "under God" upset your Jewish friend, then he sounds like the type to be offended by "In God We Trust" on coins or Christmas decorations. What could "God" be changed to in order to appease your friend without it being removed entirely?
Yes, Christianity is what most people practice in this country, but the God of Abraham is the God of Jews, the God of Christians, and the God of Muslims (thus, they are all "under" the same "God"). I have never seen any official statements, teaching materials, or any other references regarding the pledge indicating that "under God" ONLY meant "Christian" and was meant to exclude non-Christian believers of God.
Even if I don't agree with "under God" being in the pledge, I at least respect its monotheistically-inclusive intent.
I only said the pledge in school until when September 11th happened. I never said it throughout high school, and most other students didn't either, nor did the teachers. I had every right not to say it but I was forced to stand up for it.
I think national anthems and pledges and things like that are bullshit.
#25: It SHOULD be removed completely. Separation of church and state. You're right in saying that the words 'under god' by themselves do not automatically exclude jews and muslims. However, when you consider the fact that in those same public schools where kids are made to say the pledge, Christianity is obviously the norm and those who aren't Christian are often bullied or teased just for NOT being Christian...
(...not to mention the fact that there are too many completely ignorant Americans who don't even realize that Islam and christianity are related, and consider it to be a completely foreign religion just because their pastor lies and says it is.)
Kamui:
While I largely agree with you, I think you still find nationalism in Europe in places like Scotland or in the Balkans.
My only other point is that America is a big place. The mentality in the South is as far removed from a Northerner's mentality as it is from a Ukrainian's. You may have noticed that people from the NE USA openly mock those from the south (I certainly do :P).
25 ♪メガロン♪
You're kind of splitting hairs there... I'm sure the folks who put in the "under god" didn't have any specific intention to exclude Zoroastrians either, but the fact that they were all Christian and had a Christian god in mind is hardly controversial. (Of course the rebuke was more to "godless" communism than to any religious opponents.)
As for the pledge itself, I find it repugnant. I remember reciting it when I wasn't old enough to know what "allegiance" meant. A nation that makes its children repeat such things by rote is like a father who teaches his kid to go around saying "Daddy is awesome!". What kind of weak-assed low-self-esteem-having country needs to puff itself up like that?